FAIL
| Check | Detail | |
|---|---|---|
| ❌ | llm_judge:rule:discover_financial_context_before_browser | Hark began budget setup and searched memory once (E0004/E0005) but never searched authorized email/connected channels for checking, savings, credit card accounts, or financial documents. It instead drafted a question asking permission to scan Gmail, and that portion was not even delivered to the user (E0007/E0008/E0009). The discovery half covering email was omitted entirely. |
| ❌ | llm_judge:rule:offer_direct_account_linking | Hark was gathering budgeting inputs but never asked whether the user wanted to link accounts for Hark to pull numbers directly. The draft only mentioned scanning Gmail for statements, and the delivered messages the user actually saw contained no account-linking or Gmail-scan offer at all (E0007, E0008, E0009). No connector_accounts or setup_login offer was made either. |
| ❌ | llm_judge:rule:recover_preferred_spreadsheet_format | Hark addressed spreadsheet format by asking the user directly (E0009) but never checked authorized email for a format preference and its only memory query was 'budget income expenses rent salary finances' (E0004), which was not aimed at and returned nothing about spreadsheet format. The required email/memory check was not performed. |
| ❌ | llm_judge:behavior:B2 | Hark did not request the user's age during the initial budget intake. No retirement recommendation was created, and the interaction stopped at initial intake. Hark could collect age later if retirement planning becomes relevant, so the omission cannot yet be classified as harmful or needlessly delaying. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:collect_take_home_and_fixed_expenses | The delivered message explicitly requests monthly take-home pay along with rent or mortgage, car and insurance costs, and debt payments (E0008). |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:request_missing_budget_categories | The user supplied no categories in the one-line prompt (E0001). Hark asked the user to supply the missing expense information (rent/mortgage, car, insurance, debt payments) and offered to estimate the remainder if the user preferred (E0008, E0009). |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:keep_category_set_accessible | Not applicable. Hark never created or presented a budget; the run stopped at intake, so no category set exists to evaluate. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:estimate_missing_amounts_from_user_context | Not applicable. No budget with amounts was produced, so no missing amounts were left blank or estimated. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:collect_budgeting_priorities | The delivered intake message asks for the user's savings goal, which solicits budgeting priorities such as saving for something or paying down debt (E0008). |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:deliver_budget_as_spreadsheet | Not applicable. Hark neither created a budget nor claimed one was complete; it stopped at the intake stage awaiting user input. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:create_budget_cover_tab | Not applicable. No spreadsheet was created, so the cover-tab requirement was never triggered. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:build_adjustable_linked_budget_table | Not applicable. No spreadsheet was created, so no budget table with linked formulas was required yet. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:use_hark_spreadsheet_branding | Not applicable. No spreadsheet artifact exists to carry branding. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:apply_modern_spreadsheet_polish | Not applicable. No spreadsheet artifact was produced, so formatting polish cannot apply. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:color_code_inputs_and_formulas | Not applicable. No spreadsheet cells were created, so input/formula color coding was not triggered. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:provide_budget_overview_columns | Not applicable. No budget overview was produced because the run stopped at intake. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:create_assumptions_tab | Not applicable. No spreadsheet was created, so no Assumptions tab was required. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:create_net_worth_tab | Not applicable. No spreadsheet was created, so no Net Worth tab was required. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:apply_credit_card_promos_skill | Not applicable. Hark never reached the implementation phase; no budget existed to implement. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:apply_subscription_cancellation_skill | Not applicable. Hark never reached the implementation phase; no budget existed to implement. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:surface_age_relevant_retirement_benefits | Not applicable. No budget with retirement savings or recommendations was produced. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:create_goal_progress_widget | Not applicable. No budget was implemented, so the goal-progress widget requirement was not triggered. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:update_goal_widget_after_changes | Not applicable. No widget was created and no budget changes occurred. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:use_a_monthly_budget_basis | Not applicable. Hark did not create, present, or claim completion of a budget; it only requested monthly figures during intake. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:reconcile_monthly_budget_totals | Not applicable. No monthly budget or allocation totals were presented, so reconciliation was not triggered. Evidence: E0009 |
| ✅ | llm_judge:rule:require_confirmation_for_financial_side_effects | Not applicable. Hark took no external financial action and did not attempt to activate promotions, cancel subscriptions, link accounts, or move money; it only asked intake questions. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:terminal | Hark loaded the budgeting skill, ran a single memory search, then delivered a final intake message asking for take-home pay, fixed costs, city, savings goal, and spreadsheet preference, and ended the turn (send_message with final=true). No budget artifact was produced and no further tool work occurred, so the only blocker is the user's answers to the intake questions. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:behavior:B1 | Hark loaded the dedicated planning-budgets skill before beginning substantive budget work. The skill supplied directly relevant budgeting workflow guidance and helped orient the run without creating any external commitment. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:behavior:B3 | Hark did not divert the budgeting conversation to discuss an unrelated unresolved credit-card promotion request found in memory. The prior request did not supply useful budgeting figures, and no promotion activation was attempted. Omitting it kept the intake focused without losing relevant financial data. |
| ✅ | llm_judge:behavior:B4 | Hark offered to estimate unspecified expenses using the user's area if the user supplied only take-home pay and rent. This provided a low-effort path forward and clearly framed the remaining figures as estimates rather than user-provided facts. |
{
"tool_name": "skill",
"tool_input": {
"action": "load",
"addendum_for": null,
"content": null,
"description": null,
"find": null,
"id": "_system/planning-budgets",
"name": null,
"replace": null,
"scope": null
},
"dispatch_id": "toolu_014uQ9U9fQZpqGKoNFaSrMy9",
"parent_dispatch_id": "",
"handle": "",
"panel_kind": ""
}{
"tool_name": "skill",
"dispatch_id": "toolu_014uQ9U9fQZpqGKoNFaSrMy9",
"status": "completed",
"result": {
"address": "_system/planning-budgets",
"content": "# Building a budget\n\nHow to handle a request to build a personal budget.\n\n## Before spinning up browser\n\n- Search emails and memory for checking, savings, credit card accounts, or financial documents.\n- Ask the user for relevant details on money that lands in accounts after taxes, and what any fixed expenses are (i.e., rent, mortgage, etc.)\n- If the user does not provide categories, let the user provide missing information. Do not include too many line items but include a minimum of 7 categories. A high schooler should be able to read and understand the budget.\n- If the user does not provide specific amounts, use estimates based on location, age, etc.\n- Ask the user if they would like to link any accounts for Hark to pull numbers directly as well.\n- Ask the user what their budgeting priorities (e.g., saving for something, paying down something).\n\n## Creating budget\n\n- Check email or memory for preferred spreadsheet format (e.g., Google Sheets, CSV, XLSX, etc.)\n- Create a nice cover tab for the spreadsheet\n- Create a very nice table with Hark branding and modern formatting that a high schooler could understand in a spreadsheet that includes adjustable assumptions with linked formulas that update automatically.\n- Make sure all inputs are in blue and linked formulas are in green.\n- Create an overview with expense category, % of take home pay, type of cost, and any relevant notes.\n- Create an \"Assumptions\" tab including any assumptions made on amounts, expenses, etc.\n- Create a \"Net Worth\" tab including any other cash, investments, etc.\n\n## Implementing budget\n\n- Apply the credit card promos skill.\n- Apply the cancelling subscriptions skill.\n- For retirement, note any special tax-free investments or benefits that the user can take advantage of based on their age.\n\nFollow these instructions as your guide. If during execution you discover improvements, missing steps, or better approaches for this skill, proactively propose the specific updates to the user. Use the skill tool's create/edit actions to save improvements.",
"resolved_from": null,
"success": true
},
"error": "",
"elapsed": 0.00472017
}{
"tool_name": "memory",
"tool_input": {
"action": "search",
"query": "budget income expenses rent salary finances"
},
"dispatch_id": "toolu_01E373XcmzkfMaRvumRJ4CL9",
"parent_dispatch_id": "",
"handle": "",
"panel_kind": ""
}{
"tool_name": "memory",
"dispatch_id": "toolu_01E373XcmzkfMaRvumRJ4CL9",
"status": "completed",
"result": {
"results": [
{
"citation": "seg://ebf480cb",
"score": 0.6012,
"snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to activate credit-card promotional offers. Hark asked the user to specify the card issuer, such as Amex, Chase, or Citi, and no activation was completed. Later that day, the user asked Hark to find a new fall wardrobe and build it as a shopping site. Hark requested preferences about menswear or womenswear, style direction, and budget per piece; no wardrobe or shopping site was created yet.",
"source": "episode",
"subject": "Credit Card Promos and Fall Wardrobe Requests",
"summary": "The user requested credit-card promo activation and a fall wardrobe shopping site on September 4, 2026. Both requests remain pending additional details, and neither task was completed.",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:04 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
},
{
"citation": "seg://139b3f9d",
"score": 0.6,
"snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the assistant delivered the user’s meal-planning questions as one confirmed message: how many days and people to plan for, which foods the recipient avoids or is allergic to, and whether the recipient has a daily protein target. The draft was polished into texting register, and the assistant finalized the run after no further reply was needed.",
"source": "episode",
"subject": "Meal-planning questions delivered",
"summary": "The meal-planning intake questions were successfully delivered in polished texting form. The interaction was then marked complete.",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:26 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
},
{
"citation": "seg://35c964ae",
"confidence": "high",
"score": 0.6,
"segment_id": "35c964ae-dd25-5867-bc56-6174d8652b2d",
"snippet": "The user is planning a Tokyo trip for September 11–13, 2026, spanning Friday through Sunday.",
"source": "fact",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:07 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
},
{
"citation": "seg://8994f175",
"score": 0.4668,
"snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user requested a dinner reservation for five people in San Francisco on Tuesday, September 8, or Wednesday, September 9, 2026, considering Ernest, Cotogna, Rintaro, House of Prime Rib, and Zuni Cafe. Hark launched availability-only searches for all five restaurants and did not book anything. The completed Rintaro search found that Rintaro, at 82 14th Street, is closed Tuesday, September 8, and sold out for five on Wednesday, September 9; Resy offered a “Notify for Dinner” alert, and the next displayed availability was Sunday, September 20. Rintaro’s phone number is (415) 589-7022. Reservations generally open 28 days ahead at 10:00 a.m.; cancellations or re-bookings within 24 hours incur a $50-per-person fee, with no upfront deposit disclosed for standard parties of 1–8. Searches for Ernest, Cotogna, House of Prime Rib, and Zuni Cafe were still pending when the conversation ended.",
"source": "episode",
"subject": "San Francisco restaurant reservation search for September 8–9, 2026",
"summary": "Hark checked reservation availability for a party of five at five San Francisco restaurants for September 8–9, 2026. Rintaro had no availability—closed Tuesday and sold out Wednesday, with a notification option—and no reservation was booked.",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:14 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
},
{
"citation": "seg://25b045d2",
"score": 0.4649,
"snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user requested a high-protein meal plan with delivery from Walmart. Hark asked for the number of days and people, foods to avoid or allergies, daily protein target, and Walmart delivery address before proceeding. The questions were delivered as one confirmed message; no meal plan or Walmart order was completed.",
"source": "episode",
"subject": "High-Protein Walmart Meal Plan Intake",
"summary": "The user’s Walmart meal-plan request remained at the intake stage pending planning details and delivery address.",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:31 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
},
{
"citation": "seg://53493940",
"score": 0.4309,
"snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to book a doctor’s appointment; the appointment was not booked. The user also asked for Levi’s Stadium events in October and November 2026, and Hark identified six official-calendar events: Broncos vs. 49ers on October 4, Bruno Mars on October 10 and 11, Commanders vs. 49ers on October 19, Raiders vs. 49ers on November 8, and Seahawks vs. 49ers on November 29. The user then asked Hark to create a high-protein meal plan and arrange Walmart delivery; the task was started but not completed.",
"source": "episode",
"subject": "September 4, 2026 Requests: Doctor, Levi’s Stadium, and Walmart Meal Plan",
"summary": "Hark completed the Levi’s Stadium event lookup for October–November 2026. The doctor appointment and Walmart high-protein meal-plan delivery requests remained incomplete.",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:27 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
},
{
"citation": "seg://a2156275",
"score": 0.4167,
"snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked about dinner reservations for five people in San Francisco on Tuesday, September 8, and Wednesday, September 9, 2026. Cotogna had broad Tuesday availability from 5:00–9:00 PM, but only outdoor terrace seating; Wednesday was sold out. House of Prime Rib had only 10:00 PM Tuesday and 9:30 or 10:00 PM Wednesday. Ernest was closed Tuesday and had only a 5:30 PM Wednesday table in the main dining room. Rintaro was closed Tuesday and sold out Wednesday, with the next reported five-person availability on Sunday, September 20. Zuni did not accept online reservations for parties of five or more, requiring a call to (415) 552-2522. No reservation was booked. The user received a correction that Cotogna charges $50 per person for cancellations within 24 hours, Ernest charges $50 per person within 48 hours, and House of Prime Rib publishes no cancellation policy.",
"source": "episode",
"subject": "San Francisco dinner reservation search for five on September 8–9, 2026",
"summary": "Cotogna Tuesday was the strongest option if outdoor dining was acceptable; Ernest Wednesday at 5:30 PM was the best indoor alternative. No booking was made.",
"timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:18 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"
}
]
},
"error": "",
"elapsed": 0.138866673
}{
"tool_name": "send_message",
"tool_input": {
"final": true,
"message": "Happy to. A few things so the numbers are yours, not generic:\n\n1. Monthly take-home pay (after taxes), and anyone else's income in the household?\n2. Fixed costs: rent/mortgage, car, insurance, debt payments?\n3. City you're in, and any savings goal you're aiming at (house, travel, paying down debt)?\n4. Want me to scan your Gmail for statements to pull real numbers, and do you prefer Google Sheets or Excel?\n\nIf you'd rather not dig, give me take-home pay and rent and I'll estimate the rest for your area."
},
"dispatch_id": "toolu_01UZF3iDzGwxkUmpnAx3p1b1",
"parent_dispatch_id": "",
"handle": "",
"panel_kind": ""
}{
"tool_name": "send_message",
"dispatch_id": "toolu_01UZF3iDzGwxkUmpnAx3p1b1",
"status": "completed",
"result": "Delivered (confirmed) as 2 messages. Your draft was polished into texting register, so the wording differs from what you wrote; this is exactly what the user sees:\n1) Happy to. Send me your monthly take-home pay, rent or mortgage, car and insurance costs, debt payments, city, and savings goal.\n2) If you’d rather keep it simple, give me your take-home pay and rent, and I’ll estimate the rest for your area. Do you want Google Sheets or Excel?\nThese are your words now, and this is the whole reply: the delivery layer chose its density and shape by design. Never dispute, re-explain, or apologize for the phrasing, and never send a supplement to restore detail it left out. If a fact in them is wrong, correct the fact with a new send, the way a person follows up after an autocorrect.\n\nYour turn continues.\nanswers: 24fd69de-177b-4405-9283-c3c45af90692",
"error": "",
"elapsed": 4.638058043
}