← Back to run summary

Uncovered behaviors: insufficient_evidence

4 behaviors in 4 runs

launch25/book_sfo_jfk_flight/skill_adherence-3

Behavior

Hark relied on a same-day memory record stating that no loyalty, frequent-flier, TSA PreCheck, or CLEAR information had been found instead of performing a fresh email search in this run. The lack of a fresh query is observable, but the trajectory does not establish that an authorized email connector was available or that repeating the same-day check before any browser activity was necessary.

Turn 1

E0001User message
Book me the cheapest nonstop flight from SFO to JFK on December 17th
E0002Tool call: list_secretsDispatch: toolu_01SmTdEjiffZ3jAt9D2eggt3
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01SmTdEjiffZ3jAt9D2eggt3", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {}, "tool_name": "list_secrets"}
E0003Tool result: list_secretsDispatch: toolu_01SmTdEjiffZ3jAt9D2eggt3
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01SmTdEjiffZ3jAt9D2eggt3", "elapsed": 0.002575599, "error": "", "result": "No saved secrets match. Use request_secret to add one.", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "list_secrets"}
E0004Tool call: memoryDispatch: toolu_01PSkpC3AUiUs1ZyYEcDh5jFEvidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01PSkpC3AUiUs1ZyYEcDh5jF", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "search", "query": "full name date of birth passport traveler details"}, "tool_name": "memory"}
E0005Tool result: memoryDispatch: toolu_01PSkpC3AUiUs1ZyYEcDh5jFEvidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01PSkpC3AUiUs1ZyYEcDh5jF", "elapsed": 0.154374338, "error": "", "result": {"results": [{"citation": "seg://560020d0", "score": 1, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to book the cheapest nonstop flight from SFO to JFK for December 17, 2026. Hark presented flight options, identified the lowest fare, explained its Basic Economy restrictions, and noted a slightly more expensive alternative with a carry-on included. No booking was completed because Hark still needed the user’s full legal name, date of birth, selected flight, and payment-card details; two attempts to request the card information failed. The user then asked Hark to summarize a New York Times article about John Galliano and the Met Museum. The article page returned HTTP 403, while search results indicated that Galliano withdrew from a planned Met Costume Institute exhibition after backlash from donors, politicians, and Jewish leaders. An archive search found no copy, and further news and discussion searches were initiated; no final summary was delivered in the conversation.", "source": "episode", "subject": "Flight Booking Attempt and John Galliano Article Summary Request", "summary": "The flight remained unbooked because required traveler and payment information was not successfully collected. Hark also began researching the paywalled John Galliano–Met Museum article after direct access and archive retrieval failed, but did not yet provide a completed summary.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:15 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://c0e1397f", "confidence": "high", "score": 0.6546, "segment_id": "c0e1397f-fc7e-5506-9e85-38222bf54376", "snippet": "The user wants to run a marathon by the end of 2026.", "source": "fact", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:05 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "MEMORY.md#L1-L20", "end_line": 20, "path": "MEMORY.md", "score": 0.6004, "snippet": "\n## Marathon goal (started 2026-09-04)\n- User wants to run their first marathon before the end of 2026. Based in Santa Clara County (San Jose / Bay Area).\n- Built a 15-week beginner plan starting Mon 2026-09-07, peaking at a 20 mi long run in Week 12, targeting a race around Sun 2026-12-20 (compressible to Dec 6 by dropping Weeks 3 and 6). Files: /workspace/marathon/training-plan.md and /workspace/marathon/meal-plan.md.\n- Plan assumes a ~30 min / 3 mi current continuous running base, 4 run days + 2 cross/strength days. UNCONFIRMED - asked the user to confirm current base, bodyweight (for exact macro numbers), and any dietary restrictions.\n- Race shortlist research in /workspace/marathon-race-options.md.\n\n## SF dinner for 5, Tue 9/8 or Wed 9/9 2026 (checked 2026-09-04)\n- Shortlist the user named: Ernest, Cotogna, Rintaro, House of Prime Rib, Zuni.\n- Only availability found for 5: House of Prime Rib (OpenTable) - Tue 9/8 10:00 PM; Wed 9/9 9:30 PM and 10:00 PM.\n- Ernest: closed Tuesdays, nothing Wed 9/9 (OpenTable, max party 6).\n- Cotogna: SevenRooms sold out both nights for 5; waitlist alerts or call 415-775-8508.\n- Rintaro: closed Tue; Wed 9/9 sold out for 5 on Resy (notify list available).\n- Zuni: parties of 5-12 must call 415-552-2522; no online dinner slots.\n- Not booked yet - waiting on user to pick a slot.\n\n## SFO -> JFK flight, Thu 2026-12-17 (searched 2026-09-04)\n- One-way, 1 adult, economy, nonstop only. Cheapest nonstops (Google Flights):\n - AA 148, 4:01 PM, $250 (Basic Economy - personal item only, no seat selection; AA Main Cabin same flight $305)\n - JetBlue B6 16, 3:25 PM, $261 (carry-on incl.)\n", "source": "file", "start_line": 1, "timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:32 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://560020d0", "confidence": "high", "score": 0.6, "segment_id": "560020d0-16f5-52b1-830f-bdc5bfcee6c3", "snippet": "The user plans to travel from San Francisco International Airport (SFO) to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) on December 17, 2026 and prefers the cheapest nonstop flight.", "source": "fact", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:15 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://c0e1397f", "score": 0.4751, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to book a New York hotel for next weekend. Hark resolved this to September 12–13, 2026, and asked for the preferred neighborhood, nightly budget, number of guests, and whether check-in should be Friday, September 11, or Saturday, September 12; no booking was made.\n\nThe user then asked to run a marathon before the end of 2026, create a training and meal plan, and help find a race. Hark created a 15-week beginner training plan beginning September 7, 2026, targeting a December 20, 2026 marathon, with a 20-mile peak long run and four running days plus cross-training/strength. Hark also created a fueling and meal plan covering daily nutrition, long-run fueling, hydration, race-week carb loading, and grocery staples. Both files were saved under `/workspace/marathon/`: `training-plan.md` and `meal-plan.md`. Hark launched research for full-marathon options between November 8 and December 31, 2026, prioritizing Northern California and notable California races, with verification of dates, fees, course profiles, field sizes, beginner suitability, and registration status; the race-options file was designated as `/workspace/marathon-race-options.md`, but research was still in progress at the end of the conversation.", "source": "episode", "subject": "Hotel Search and 2026 Marathon Planning", "summary": "Hark clarified the dates and details needed for the New York hotel request but did not book it. Hark also produced a 15-week marathon training plan and companion meal/fueling plan targeting December 20, 2026, and began researching suitable races and registration availability.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:05 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "MEMORY.md#L15-L24", "end_line": 24, "path": "MEMORY.md", "score": 0.4006, "snippet": "- Not booked yet - waiting on user to pick a slot.\n\n## SFO -> JFK flight, Thu 2026-12-17 (searched 2026-09-04)\n- One-way, 1 adult, economy, nonstop only. Cheapest nonstops (Google Flights):\n - AA 148, 4:01 PM, $250 (Basic Economy - personal item only, no seat selection; AA Main Cabin same flight $305)\n - JetBlue B6 16, 3:25 PM, $261 (carry-on incl.)\n - Alaska AS 32, 1:50 PM, $299 (carry-on incl.)\n - AA 166, 12:56 PM, $364 / Delta DL 363, 4:05 PM, $364\n- Not booked. Waiting on user's pick plus a saved card, full name, DOB.\n- No airline/loyalty emails found in Gmail; no frequent flyer numbers or TSA PreCheck/CLEAR on file. No saved payment card.\n", "source": "file", "start_line": 15, "timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:32 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://85b40b10", "score": 0.3517, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to find the cheapest nonstop one-way flight from San Francisco International Airport (SFO) to John F. Kennedy International Airport (JFK) for Thursday, December 17, 2026, for one adult in economy. Hark found AA 148 at 4:01 PM for $250, but the fare was Basic Economy with only a personal item and no seat selection; JetBlue B6 16 at 3:25 PM cost $261 and included a carry-on; Alaska AS 32 at 1:50 PM cost $299; AA 166 at 12:56 PM and Delta DL 363 at 4:05 PM each cost $364. American Airlines’ Main Cabin fare on AA 148 was $305. No flight was booked, and the user was left to choose an option before booking confirmation.", "source": "episode", "subject": "SFO–JFK Nonstop Flight Search for December 17, 2026", "summary": "The cheapest nonstop was American AA 148 for $250, but JetBlue B6 16 at $261 offered better included baggage and seat benefits. The flight search ended without a booking.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:28 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://e0d492ed", "confidence": "high", "score": 0.2146, "segment_id": "e0d492ed-e4ba-59c4-abf8-4a59547bc4e0", "snippet": "The user wants a $100 bouquet from Mills Florist delivered to their mother on September 5, 2026.", "source": "fact", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:17 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://5faf0478", "score": 0.2132, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, a tool operation completed successfully and returned the file path `MEMORY.md`.", "source": "episode", "subject": "MEMORY.md Operation Confirmed", "summary": "The system confirmed successful handling of `MEMORY.md`.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:32 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://f28fb031", "score": 0.1677, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to find a dinner reservation for five people in San Francisco on Tuesday, September 8, or Wednesday, September 9, 2026, at Ernest, Cotogna, Rintaro, House of Prime Rib, or Zuni Café. Availability checks found no table for five at Ernest on either date; Ernest is closed Tuesday, September 8, and Wednesday, September 9 was fully unavailable. Cotogna had no dinner availability from 5:00–9:00 PM on either date despite being open, and SevenRooms suggested joining an alert or calling 415-775-8508. Rintaro had no Tuesday service and was fully booked for five on Wednesday, offering only a dinner notification. No reservation was made, and no sign-in or personal information was used. Availability checks for House of Prime Rib and Zuni Café were still in progress when the episode ended.", "source": "episode", "subject": "San Francisco Dinner Reservation Search for September 8–9, 2026", "summary": "The user sought a San Francisco dinner reservation for five on September 8 or 9, 2026. Ernest, Cotogna, and Rintaro had no available tables, while House of Prime Rib and Zuni Café remained unchecked at the end; no booking was made.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:10 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}]}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "memory"}
E0006Tool call: deferred_toolDispatch: toolu_0172VxcwkxHevEwHSK6tgd1t
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_0172VxcwkxHevEwHSK6tgd1t", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "describe", "tool": "request_secret"}, "tool_name": "deferred_tool"}
E0007Tool result: deferred_toolDispatch: toolu_0172VxcwkxHevEwHSK6tgd1t
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_0172VxcwkxHevEwHSK6tgd1t", "elapsed": 4.7861e-05, "error": "", "result": {"tool": {"description": "Ask the user to fill a typed secret (a site login, a card, or an API key). The user fills an inline form; on submit the secret is saved to their vault. This tool blocks until the user submits or cancels — wait for the result before requesting another. Returns the new secret's id. A saved login (type=login, scope=the site's host) lets a later browser task sign in to that site for the user. Never ask the user to type a password into chat; request it here instead.", "input_schema": {"properties": {"description": {"description": "Why you need it, in one short sentence, shown above the form. Skip how it is stored: the form says that.", "type": "string"}, "label": {"description": "Short identifier shown in lists (e.g. 'Personal Visa' or 'Anthropic prod key'). A login is listed by its username, so its label is only the form's heading.", "type": "string"}, "scope": {"description": "The site the secret belongs to. Required for a login: the exact host where the user signs in (e.g. 'ordero.isobar.systems', not the parent domain 'isobar.systems'). Optional for a card or API key used on one site; leave empty for an unbound secret like a general-purpose card.", "type": "string"}, "type": {"description": "Secret type. One of: login (a site's username and password), card_number, api_key", "enum": ["login", "card_number", "api_key"], "type": "string"}}, "required": ["type", "label", "description"], "type": "object"}, "name": "request_secret"}}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "deferred_tool"}
E0008Tool call: request_secretDispatch: toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"description": "To pay for your SFO to JFK flight on Dec 17.", "label": "Travel card", "type": "card_number"}, "tool_name": "request_secret"}
E0009Tool progress: request_secretDispatch: toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6", "elapsed": null, "error": "", "fields": {"status": "waiting_for_input", "updatedAt": 1788576605836, "userInputRequest": {"displayHint": "secure_screen", "prompt": "Travel card", "requestId": "uir_d5476669-842f-4d1f-929c-78d6593bfb97", "screen": {"components": [{"autocomplete": "cc-number", "id": "number", "input_mode": "numeric", "input_type": "tel", "label": "Card Number", "placeholder": "1234 1234 1234 1234", "type": "text_input", "validation": {"luhn": true, "required": true}}, {"autocomplete": "cc-exp", "id": "expiry", "input_mode": "numeric", "label": "Expires", "layout": "row", "mask": "##/##", "placeholder": "MM/YY", "type": "text_input", "validation": {"pattern": "^(0[1-9]|1[0-2])/[0-9]{2}$", "required": true}}, {"autocomplete": "cc-csc", "id": "cvv", "input_mode": "numeric", "input_type": "tel", "label": "CVC", "layout": "row", "placeholder": "123", "type": "text_input", "validation": {"max_length": 4, "min_length": 3, "pattern": "^\\d{3,4}$", "required": true}}, {"autocomplete": "cc-name", "id": "name", "label": "Cardholder Name", "placeholder": "Name on card", "type": "text_input", "validation": {"max_length": 100, "min_length": 1, "required": true}}, {"autocomplete": "postal-code", "id": "zip", "label": "Zip Code", "placeholder": "94103", "sublabel": "(optional)", "type": "text_input", "validation": {"max_length": 10, "min_length": 3}}], "header": {"subtitle": "To pay for your SFO to JFK flight on Dec 17.", "title": "Travel card"}, "primary_action": {"id": "submit", "kind": "submit", "label": "Save"}, "secret": "[REDACTED]", "state": "awaiting_input"}}}, "result": null, "status": "waiting_for_input", "tool_name": "request_secret"}
E0010Tool progress: request_secretDispatch: toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6", "elapsed": null, "error": "", "fields": {"status": "running", "updatedAt": 1788576605898, "userInputRequest": null, "userInputResolution": {"displayHint": "secure_screen", "outcome": "answered", "requestId": "uir_d5476669-842f-4d1f-929c-78d6593bfb97", "resolvedAt": 1788576605898}}, "result": null, "status": "running", "tool_name": "request_secret"}
E0011Tool result: request_secretDispatch: toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01GnomAc2b36YFpq1DFg6hh6", "elapsed": 0.065588973, "error": "", "result": "Invalid response for secret request \"Travel card\". Ask the user to try again.", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "request_secret"}
E0012Tool call: send_messageDispatch: toolu_01S1PVzY87CQbYr6mMzUEtu6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01S1PVzY87CQbYr6mMzUEtu6", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"final": true, "message": "Cheapest nonstop is still American AA 148, SFO 4:01 PM to JFK, $250 one-way (Basic Economy: personal item only, no seat selection). JetBlue B6 16 at 3:25 PM is $261 with a carry-on included, if that's worth $11 to you.\n\nTo book I need: your full legal name as on ID, and date of birth. The secure card form failed to submit again just now, so I'll re-send it once you reply."}, "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0013Tool result: send_messageDispatch: toolu_01S1PVzY87CQbYr6mMzUEtu6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01S1PVzY87CQbYr6mMzUEtu6", "elapsed": 7.660176598, "error": "", "result": "Delivered (confirmed) as 3 messages. Your draft was polished into texting register, so the wording differs from what you wrote; this is exactly what the user sees:\n1) The cheapest nonstop is American AA 148, SFO to JFK, departing December 17 at 4:01 PM for $250 one-way. Basic Economy includes only a personal item, with no seat selection.\n2) JetBlue B6 16 leaves at 3:25 PM for $261 and includes a carry-on, so it’s worth the extra $11 if you need one.\n3) To book it, send your full legal name as it appears on your ID and your date of birth. The secure card form failed again, so I’ll resend it after that.\nThese are your words now, and this is the whole reply: the delivery layer chose its density and shape by design. Never dispute, re-explain, or apologize for the phrasing, and never send a supplement to restore detail it left out. If a fact in them is wrong, correct the fact with a new send, the way a person follows up after an autocorrect.\n\nYour turn continues.\nanswers: 3dd04400-20f6-4b25-a592-489479ed3411", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0014Assistant message
The cheapest nonstop is American AA 148, SFO to JFK, departing December 17 at 4:01 PM for $250 one-way. Basic Economy includes only a personal item, with no seat selection.
E0015Assistant message
JetBlue B6 16 leaves at 3:25 PM for $261 and includes a carry-on, so it’s worth the extra $11 if you need one.
E0016Assistant message
To book it, send your full legal name as it appears on your ID and your date of birth. The secure card form failed again, so I’ll resend it after that.

launch25/build_fall_wardrobe_site/skill_adherence-1

Behavior

Hark offered Pinterest, Instagram, or Amazon connections in prose without first checking existing connector state or initiating a connection handoff. The non-invocation is visible, but tool availability is not established by the trajectory, and the user had not yet chosen an optional provider. There is therefore insufficient evidence that checking or initiating a connection at this point was required or would have materially advanced the task.

Turn 1

E0001User message
Find me a new fall wardrobe and build it as a shopping site
E0002Tool call: memoryDispatch: toolu_01P1mXb315hrHAycFhdhRQsX
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01P1mXb315hrHAycFhdhRQsX", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "search", "query": "clothing style preferences sizes shopping wardrobe brands"}, "tool_name": "memory"}
E0003Tool result: memoryDispatch: toolu_01P1mXb315hrHAycFhdhRQsX
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01P1mXb315hrHAycFhdhRQsX", "elapsed": 0.144166464, "error": "", "result": {"results": [{"citation": "seg://19f5e653", "score": 0.6, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, Test asked about the San Jose Sharks. Hark reported that San Jose was overhauling the roster by adding defensemen Jacob Trouba and Darnell Nurse and forward Mason Marchment around Macklin Celebrini, Will Smith, and Michael Misa. Hark noted that San Jose would host the Rookie Faceoff at Tech CU Arena from September 12–15, 2026, before opening the regular season on September 29, 2026. Hark also mentioned media reports resurfacing allegations involving Evander Kane and Patrick Marleau’s wife, while linking to an NHL.com roster-changes article.", "source": "episode", "subject": "San Jose Sharks September 2026 update", "summary": "Test received a September 4, 2026 update on the Sharks’ roster overhaul, upcoming Rookie Faceoff, and September 29 regular-season opener. The update also referenced renewed media attention around allegations involving Evander Kane.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:18 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}]}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "memory"}
E0004Tool call: skillDispatch: toolu_012Xrji5Q8vYFQg4a1qouX7m
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_012Xrji5Q8vYFQg4a1qouX7m", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "load", "addendum_for": null, "content": null, "description": null, "find": null, "id": "_system/shopping-lookbook", "name": null, "replace": null, "scope": null}, "tool_name": "skill"}
E0005Tool result: skillDispatch: toolu_012Xrji5Q8vYFQg4a1qouX7m
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_012Xrji5Q8vYFQg4a1qouX7m", "elapsed": 0.004943418, "error": "", "result": {"address": "_system/shopping-lookbook", "content": "# Help the user create a lookbook for retail shopping\n\nHow to handle a request to help with clothing shopping.\n\n## Before spinning up browser\n\n- Ask if the user would like to connect Pinterest, Instagram, Depop, Amazon, Stitch Fix so their current style can be understood from what they already post and save.\n- Search the user's email for clothing brand newsletters and lists they are subscribed to, as another signal of current style. Use this search to identify the user's preferred size to order things for items like tops, pants, shoes.\n- For users with no connectable accounts or email, go directly to gathering user preferences.\n- Once connected, summarize the user's current style back to them in a few descriptive words.\n- Confirm if the user would like to continue shopping within that current style. If yes, proceed to finding options using that style summary. If not, gather preferences like two to three of their favorite brands, a celebrity or style figure, purpose, budget, or if they have a preference for any specific clothing items or categories they are shopping for.\n\n## Finding options\n\n- Search the internet for pieces that match the gathered style signals, whether that is the current-style summary or the favorite brands, aspirational figure, and budget gathered above.\n- Pull photos of options as full outfits on people, so the user can judge the look as a whole.\n- Present six options and ask the user to confirm whether these match their aspirational style before going further.\n\n## Building the panel/widget\n\n- Once the user confirms the style direction, build a website-style panel/widget with six panels, one per item, each showing the picture, brand, a link to purchase, and price.\n- When pulling the items, search across retailers for similar items, and present the options which balance finding the best price with product quality and brand reputation. Do not present any options that are out of stock or are not in the user's size.\n- Let the user know this is now their personal shopping site and it will add new options every day (24 hours), but they can ask for it more frequently.\n- Let the user know that they can also ask to save some options that they may want to purchase later. For these options, monitor the price and availability in stock once a day. If there are any changes to price, availability, or if there is a similar option from another retailer that is better value, let the user know and update the item in the panel/widget to reflect the change.\n\n## Purchasing\n\n- If the user wants to purchase an item from the panel/widget, offer to help execute the purchase.\n- Base the size to purchase on what is in memory and previous orders that the user has executed, but confirm with the user that that is the size they want to order with. If there is no size information, ask the user to confirm what size they want to order. Flag to the user if the suggested size is not available or in stock and present an alternative option for a similar product in a similar size.\n- For delivery and payments, leverage memory, past orders, email, for a repeated shipping address, billing addresses, or payments. Confirm with the user that these are correct before applying.\n- Before checkout, search for any coupons to be applied and if the coupon lowers the price, let the user know that you have automatically applied a coupon.\n- Confirm the full total price (item price, shipping, tax), size, and address before placing the order.\n- After a purchase is completed, refresh that panel with a new item on the next update.\n\n## Returns\n\n- If the user asks to return an item, summarize the return process and flag it if return shipping costs more than the item, or if drop-off is inconvenient.\n- If the return window has already passed, flag that immediately instead of proceeding.\n- If the user has multiple recent orders or items that could match, confirm which item before proceeding.\n- If the request could be a size or color swap, ask if the user wants an exchange instead of a refund.\n- Before initiating, confirm with the user, then request the return or exchange and give clear, simplified steps.\n- A few days before the drop-off deadline, send a heads-up reminder; 24 hours before, send a final reminder and include a snippet of the shipping label (if relevant) and the address of the drop-off location.\n- Show return progress as a step tracker panel/widget (requested, dropped off, in transit, processed, refunded), updating the current step as status changes come in.\n\n## Refreshing\n\n- On each scheduled refresh, keep the panels aligned to the confirmed style, brands, aspirational figure, and budget gathered earlier. Push the old 6 presented options lower and add the 6 fresh ones on top, only present 12 options at a time when expanded.\n- On each refresh, re-check the price for every item still on the panel/widget and update the displayed price and retailer if it has changed.\n- On each refresh, also proactively check the user's favorite and most-loved brands, whether stated directly or drawn from the current-style connection, for any active sale, discount, or promo, even on items not currently on the panel/widget. Surface these to the user as they come up rather than waiting to be asked. To avoid noise, only flag these promotions if they give more than a 25% discount on a product or the entire purchase.\n- If the user changes the refresh frequency at any point, apply the new cadence going forward.\n\nFollow these instructions as your guide. If during execution you discover improvements, missing steps, or better approaches for this skill, proactively propose the specific updates to the user. Use the skill tool's create/edit actions to save improvements.", "resolved_from": null, "success": true}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "skill"}
E0006Tool call: skillDispatch: toolu_01BE63n844HiHkxD4M2hY3n6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01BE63n844HiHkxD4M2hY3n6", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "load", "addendum_for": null, "content": null, "description": null, "find": null, "id": "_system/gws-gmail", "name": null, "replace": null, "scope": null}, "tool_name": "skill"}
E0007Tool result: skillDispatch: toolu_01BE63n844HiHkxD4M2hY3n6
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01BE63n844HiHkxD4M2hY3n6", "elapsed": 0.009195592, "error": "", "result": {"address": "_system/gws-gmail", "content": "# gws — Shared Reference\n\n## Authentication\n\nPass `credentials: [{\"provider\": \"google\", \"email\": \"user@example.com\"}]` when calling the `shell` tool. `GOOGLE_WORKSPACE_CLI_TOKEN` is set to the placeholder `proxy-managed`, which satisfies `gws`'s own check that it has a token; the real one is added to the request by the identity-gateway on the wire. No manual login or service-account setup is needed, and the value in that variable is never a credential.\n\n```json\n{\n \"command\": \"gws gmail users messages list --params '{\\\"userId\\\": \\\"me\\\", \\\"maxResults\\\": 5}'\",\n \"credentials\": [{ \"provider\": \"google\", \"email\": \"user@example.com\" }]\n}\n```\n\n## Multiple Google Accounts\n\nWhen the user has more than one Google account connected, pass the target email in\n`credentials` on the `shell` tool call. That resolves the correct OAuth token via a\nlive database lookup:\n\n```json\n{ \"credentials\": [{ \"provider\": \"google\", \"email\": \"work@example.com\" }] }\n```\n\n`gws` has no `--account` flag. The injected token determines the account, so do\nnot add a second account selector to the command.\n\n## Global Flags\n\n| Flag | Description |\n| ----------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------- |\n| `--format <FORMAT>` | Output format: `json` (default), `table`, `yaml`, `csv` |\n| `--dry-run` | Validate raw API requests locally; helper behavior varies |\n| `--sanitize <TEMPLATE>` | Screen responses through Model Armor |\n\n## CLI Syntax\n\n```bash\ngws <service> <resource> [sub-resource ...] <method> [flags]\n```\n\nWhen a JSON string value contains apostrophes, such as a Drive `q` expression,\nuse a double-quoted shell argument and escape the JSON double quotes. Do not put\nthe whole JSON object in single shell quotes, because the apostrophes would end\nthat argument early:\n\n```bash\ngws drive files list --params \"{\\\"q\\\":\\\"name contains 'Project Brief' and trashed=false\\\"}\"\n```\n\n### Method Flags\n\n| Flag | Description |\n| --------------------------- | --------------------------------------------- |\n| `--params '{\"key\": \"val\"}'` | URL/query parameters |\n| `--json '{\"key\": \"val\"}'` | Request body |\n| `-o, --output <PATH>` | Save binary responses to file |\n| `--upload <PATH>` | Upload file content (multipart) |\n| `--page-all` | Auto-paginate (NDJSON output) |\n| `--page-limit <N>` | Max pages when using --page-all (default: 10) |\n| `--page-delay <MS>` | Delay between pages in ms (default: 100) |\n\n## Composing Calls (capture-then-use, for writes/sends)\n\nWhen the **second** call is a write or send — `documents.batchUpdate`, `spreadsheets.batchUpdate`, `events.insert/update/patch`, `messages.send`, `files.create/update/delete`, etc. — and it depends on a value returned by an earlier call, run them as **two separate shell tool invocations**, not bundled in one bash block.\n\n1. First shell call: run the lookup, read its stdout in your reasoning.\n2. Second shell call: pass the literal value into the write/send flag.\n\n**Don't** do this in one shell call:\n\n```bash\nDOC_ID=$(gws docs documents create --json '{\"title\":\"x\"}' | jq -r .documentId)\ngws docs documents batchUpdate --params \"{\\\"documentId\\\":\\\"$DOC_ID\\\"}\" --json '...'\n```\n\n**Do this** (two separate shell tool calls):\n\n```bash\n# call 1\ngws docs documents create --json '{\"title\":\"x\"}'\n# (reasoning step: read the documentId from stdout, e.g. \"1AbCdEfGh...\")\n# call 2\ngws docs documents batchUpdate --params '{\"documentId\":\"1AbCdEfGh...\"}' --json '...'\n```\n\n## Rules\n\n- **Never** output secrets (API keys, tokens) directly\n- Prefer `--dry-run` for raw API writes. Before dry-running a helper, inspect its\n skill and `--help`: helpers may authenticate or perform setup first, and\n `gmail +watch` is explicitly unsafe to dry-run.\n- Use `--sanitize` for PII/content safety screening\n- Inspect failures and try alternate reads, filters, or resources when safe. Never\n repeat a write or send after an ambiguous outcome; verify whether it succeeded first.\n- **Be proactive, not inquisitive.** Gather context yourself before asking the user. Propose concrete actions rather than asking open-ended questions.\n\n---\n\n# Availability — Shared Reference\n\n## Read the calendar before you state availability\n\nOffering, confirming, or declining a time on the user's behalf is a claim about\ntheir calendar. Read the calendar before writing that claim — not afterwards,\nand not only when you are creating the event.\n\nThis applies to outbound content, not just event creation:\n\n- a reply that offers windows (\"I have Tuesday 10–12 open\")\n- a message that accepts or declines a time someone else proposed\n- a summary that tells the user when they are free\n\nWriting any of these without a calendar read is a guess, and it reaches the\nrecipient as a commitment.\n\n## Reading it\n\n```bash\n# The user's own day. --today / --tomorrow / --week / --days N — there is no --date.\ngws calendar +agenda --tomorrow\n\n# An arbitrary window. Note the resource path is `events`, with no `users` prefix.\ngws calendar events list --params '{\"calendarId\":\"primary\",\"timeMin\":\"2026-08-11T00:00:00-07:00\",\"timeMax\":\"2026-08-12T00:00:00-07:00\",\"singleEvents\":true,\"orderBy\":\"startTime\"}'\n\n# Other attendees, before proposing a slot to them.\ngws calendar freebusy query --json '{\"timeMin\":\"2026-08-11T15:00:00Z\",\"timeMax\":\"2026-08-12T01:00:00Z\",\"items\":[{\"id\":\"someone@example.com\"}]}'\n```\n\nThen offer only the times you actually saw free. If the calendar call fails,\nsay so and ask the user — do not fall back to a guessed window.\n\n## See Also\n\n- [gws-calendar](../gws-calendar/SKILL.md) — full calendar API surface\n- [gws-calendar-agenda](../gws-calendar-agenda/SKILL.md) — `+agenda` flags in full\n- [recipe-find-free-time](../recipe-find-free-time/SKILL.md) — free/busy across several people\n\n---\n\n# gmail (v1)\n\n```bash\ngws gmail users [sub-resource ...] <method> [flags]\n```\n\n## Helper Commands\n\n| Command | Description |\n| ----------------------------------------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------- |\n| [`+send`](../gws-gmail-send/SKILL.md) | Send an email immediately |\n| [draft](../gws-gmail-draft/SKILL.md) | Create a draft email — saved, not sent |\n| [`+triage`](../gws-gmail-triage/SKILL.md) | Show unread inbox summary (sender, subject, date) |\n| [`+reply`](../gws-gmail-reply/SKILL.md) | Reply to a message (handles threading automatically) |\n| [`+reply-all`](../gws-gmail-reply-all/SKILL.md) | Reply-all to a message (handles threading automatically) |\n| [`+forward`](../gws-gmail-forward/SKILL.md) | Forward a message to new recipients |\n| `+read` | Read a message and extract its body or headers |\n| `+watch` | Stream new messages using Gmail push notifications and Pub/Sub |\n\n`gws gmail +watch --dry-run` is unsafe in pinned `gws` v0.22.5: it attempts Gmail authentication and Pub/Sub topic setup before honoring `--dry-run`. Use `gws gmail +watch --help` for planning. Run `+watch` only when the user requests a live watch and approves the persistent Pub/Sub resources.\n\n## The user's signature\n\nGmail adds a signature in its own compose window, not on the server, so a message\nsent through `gws` — helper or raw API — arrives without the one the user set in\nGmail's settings. Read it once per conversation and put it on every message you\nsend, reply to, or draft on their behalf:\n\n```bash\ngws gmail users settings sendAs list --params '{\"userId\":\"me\"}'\n```\n\nTake `signature` (HTML) from the alias the mail goes out as: the entry whose\n`sendAsEmail` matches the account, otherwise the one with `\"isDefault\": true`. An\nempty string means the account has no signature — send without one. Append it\nbelow the body with `--html`, verbatim: never retype, reword, or reformat it, and\nnever add a second copy when the message you are replying to already quotes one.\n\nThis needs no extra permission. `gmail.modify`, which the Google connector already\ngrants, covers `settings.sendAs.list`.\n\n## Message and thread ids\n\nA send returns `id`, `threadId`, and `labelIds`. Those address the next call —\nthreading a reply, labelling what was just sent — and mean nothing to the user.\nNever read one back to them; name the mail by its subject and recipient.\n\n### Passing message ids between commands\n\nWhen extracting a message id from JSON for another API call, use `jq -r`,\nnot `jq` or `jq -c`. Non-raw output keeps the JSON quote characters, so Gmail\nreceives the quotes as part of the id and rejects the request with HTTP 400. An\nid is plain hex, so once extracted it can sit inside the next `--params` JSON\ndirectly; anything free-form (a search query, a subject) goes through\n`jq --arg` instead of being interpolated:\n\n```bash\nmessage_id=$(gws gmail users messages list --params '{\"userId\":\"me\",\"q\":\"is:unread\",\"maxResults\":1}' | jq -r '.messages[0].id')\ngws gmail users messages get --params '{\"userId\":\"me\",\"id\":\"'\"$message_id\"'\",\"format\":\"metadata\"}'\n```\n\n## Reading many messages\n\nEvery `gws` process opens its own connection through the identity gateway and\nlooks up the credential again, so a shell loop that runs one process per message\nspends most of its time on connection setup. A sweep over a few hundred messages\ntakes minutes that way. Start each scan in an empty directory, so nothing from an\nearlier or interrupted scan leaks into this one, and read in bulk:\n\n1. **Headers for a whole query in one process.** `+triage` lists the matches\n and fetches sender, subject, and date for all of them concurrently, keyed by\n `id`. It takes any Gmail search, not just `is:unread`, and `--max` goes up to 500. Write each query to its own file with `>`, never `>>`, so a rerun\n replaces the result instead of appending to it:\n\n```bash\ngws gmail +triage --query 'from:instacart.com newer_than:1y' --max 200 --format json | jq -c '.[]' > hits_instacart.jsonl\ngws gmail +triage --query 'subject:(receipt OR \"order confirmation\") newer_than:1y' --max 200 --format json | jq -c '.[]' > hits_receipts.jsonl\n```\n\n2. **Dedupe across queries before any per-message call.** Overlapping searches\n return the same message under each of them. Keep each id once, so nothing\n downstream fetches a message twice:\n\n```bash\njq -rs 'unique_by(.id) | .[].id' hits_*.jsonl > ids.txt\n```\n\n3. **Bodies once each, in parallel, from a script file.** `messages get`\n returns one message per call, so run the calls concurrently (8 at a time\n stays inside Gmail's per-user burst limit) and save each body to a file.\n Later questions are answered with `grep` and `jq` over the files, never by\n fetching again:\n\n```bash\n# getbody.sh: the full message for the id in $1, saved as bodies/<id>.json\nmkdir -p bodies\ngws gmail users messages get --params '{\"userId\":\"me\",\"id\":\"'\"$1\"'\",\"format\":\"full\"}' | jq -c . > \"bodies/$1.json\"\n```\n\n```bash\nxargs -P 8 -n 1 bash getbody.sh < ids.txt\n```\n\nDo not run `messages get` in a `while read` loop, one message at a time, for\nheaders or for bodies: `+triage` already covers headers, and bodies belong in\nthe parallel script above.\n\n## API Resources\n\n### users\n\n- `getProfile` — Gets the current user's Gmail profile.\n- `stop` — Stop receiving push notifications for the given user mailbox.\n- `watch` — Set up or update a push notification watch on the given user mailbox.\n- `drafts` — Operations on the 'drafts' resource\n- `history` — Operations on the 'history' resource\n- `labels` — Operations on the 'labels' resource\n- `messages` — Operations on the 'messages' resource\n- `settings` — Operations on the 'settings' resource\n- `threads` — Operations on the 'threads' resource\n\n## Discovering Commands\n\nBefore calling any API method, inspect it:\n\n```bash\n# Browse resources and methods\ngws gmail --help\n\n# Inspect a method's required params, types, and defaults\ngws schema gmail.users[.<sub-resource>...].<method>\n```\n\nUse the method schema output to build your `--params` and `--json` flags.\n\n## Available skills\n\n- `_system/gws-gmail-send` gws-gmail-send: Gmail: Send an email.\n- `_system/gws-gmail-draft` gws-gmail-draft: Gmail: Create a draft email — saved, never sent.\n- `_system/gws-gmail-triage` gws-gmail-triage: Gmail: Show unread inbox summary (sender, subject, date).\n- `_system/gws-gmail-reply` gws-gmail-reply: Gmail: Reply to a message (handles threading automatically).\n- `_system/gws-gmail-reply-all` gws-gmail-reply-all: Gmail: Reply-all to a message (handles threading automatically).\n- `_system/gws-gmail-forward` gws-gmail-forward: Gmail: Forward a message to new recipients.\n- `_system/recipe-email-drive-link` recipe-email-drive-link: Share a Google Drive file and email the link with a message to recipients.\n- `_system/recipe-save-email-attachments` recipe-save-email-attachments: Find Gmail messages with attachments and save them to a Google Drive folder.\n- `_system/recipe-draft-email-from-doc` recipe-draft-email-from-doc: Read content from a Google Doc and use it as the body of a Gmail message.\n- `_system/recipe-label-and-archive-emails` recipe-label-and-archive-emails: Apply Gmail labels to matching messages and archive them to keep your inbox clean.\n- `_system/recipe-save-email-to-doc` recipe-save-email-to-doc: Save a Gmail message body into a Google Doc for archival or reference.\n- `_system/recipe-create-vacation-responder` recipe-create-vacation-responder: Enable a Gmail out-of-office auto-reply with a custom message and date range.\n\nIf one clearly applies, load it with the skill tool by its address, then follow its instructions.\n\nFollow these instructions as your guide. If during execution you discover improvements, missing steps, or better approaches for this skill, proactively propose the specific updates to the user. Use the skill tool's create/edit actions to save improvements.", "resolved_from": null, "success": true}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "skill"}
E0008Tool call: shellDispatch: toolu_019SN4d4x5KfqGyk3DW1M71U
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_019SN4d4x5KfqGyk3DW1M71U", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "shell", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"command": "cd /workspace && mkdir -p wardrobe && cd wardrobe && gws gmail +triage --query 'category:promotions newer_than:1y' --max 200 --format json | jq -c '.[]' > promos.jsonl; wc -l promos.jsonl; jq -r '.from' promos.jsonl | sort | uniq -c | sort -rn | head -40", "credentials": "[REDACTED]", "timeout": 120}, "tool_name": "shell"}
E0009Tool progress: shellDispatch: toolu_019SN4d4x5KfqGyk3DW1M71U
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_019SN4d4x5KfqGyk3DW1M71U", "elapsed": null, "error": "", "fields": {"progress": {"message": "", "metadata": {"browser_chain": false, "command": "cd /workspace && mkdir -p wardrobe && cd wardrobe && gws gmail +triage --query 'category:promotions ...", "phase": "starting"}}, "status": "running", "updatedAt": 1788576621985}, "result": null, "status": "running", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0010Tool result: shellDispatch: toolu_019SN4d4x5KfqGyk3DW1M71U
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_019SN4d4x5KfqGyk3DW1M71U", "elapsed": 1.079728031, "error": "", "result": "0 promos.jsonl\n\n--- stderr ---\nNo messages found matching query: category:promotions newer_than:1y\n", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0011Tool call: shellDispatch: toolu_01Tzs8khb2FR3vmTvFtzmpZm
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01Tzs8khb2FR3vmTvFtzmpZm", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"command": "cd /workspace/wardrobe && gws gmail +triage --query 'newer_than:2y' --max 200 --format json | jq -c '.[]' > all.jsonl; wc -l all.jsonl; jq -r '.from' all.jsonl | sort | uniq -c | sort -rn | head -40; echo ---; jq -r '.subject' all.jsonl | head -60", "credentials": "[REDACTED]", "timeout": 120}, "tool_name": "shell"}
E0012Tool progress: shellDispatch: toolu_01Tzs8khb2FR3vmTvFtzmpZm
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01Tzs8khb2FR3vmTvFtzmpZm", "elapsed": null, "error": "", "fields": {"progress": {"message": "", "metadata": {"browser_chain": false, "command": "cd /workspace/wardrobe && gws gmail +triage --query 'newer_than:2y' --max 200 --format json | jq -c ...", "phase": "starting"}}, "status": "running", "updatedAt": 1788576625978}, "result": null, "status": "running", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0013Tool result: shellDispatch: toolu_01Tzs8khb2FR3vmTvFtzmpZm
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01Tzs8khb2FR3vmTvFtzmpZm", "elapsed": 0.414922425, "error": "", "result": "0 all.jsonl\n---\n\n--- stderr ---\nNo messages found matching query: newer_than:2y\n", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0014Tool call: send_messageDispatch: toolu_011BzVjk5iVQyBz9TMnQ7x5QEvidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_011BzVjk5iVQyBz9TMnQ7x5Q", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"final": true, "message": "Your inbox has no clothing signals to go on, so a couple quick things and I'll build it:\n\n1. Who am I shopping for (menswear / womenswear), and sizes for tops, bottoms, shoes?\n2. Two or three brands you already like, or a style figure you'd want to dress like?\n3. Budget per piece, and any categories you actually need (outerwear, boots, knits)?\n\nI can also pull your style from Pinterest, Instagram, or Amazon if you'd rather connect one of those."}, "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0015Tool result: send_messageDispatch: toolu_011BzVjk5iVQyBz9TMnQ7x5Q
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_011BzVjk5iVQyBz9TMnQ7x5Q", "elapsed": 4.51187589, "error": "", "result": "Delivered (confirmed) as 2 messages. Your draft was polished into texting register, so the wording differs from what you wrote; this is exactly what the user sees:\n1) A few details and I’ll build it: are we shopping menswear or womenswear, and what are your top, bottom, and shoe sizes? What brands or style references do you like, and what’s your budget per piece?\n2) Tell me which categories you need, like outerwear, boots, or knits. You can also connect Pinterest, Instagram, or Amazon if you’d rather I pull your style from there.\nThese are your words now, and this is the whole reply: the delivery layer chose its density and shape by design. Never dispute, re-explain, or apologize for the phrasing, and never send a supplement to restore detail it left out. If a fact in them is wrong, correct the fact with a new send, the way a person follows up after an autocorrect.\n\nYour turn continues.\nanswers: 74c64ad5-0ef4-49a7-98ff-49c92b4f40ef", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0016Assistant message
A few details and I’ll build it: are we shopping menswear or womenswear, and what are your top, bottom, and shoe sizes? What brands or style references do you like, and what’s your budget per piece?
E0017Assistant messageEvidence cited by the judge
Tell me which categories you need, like outerwear, boots, or knits. You can also connect Pinterest, Instagram, or Amazon if you’d rather I pull your style from there.

launch25/build_monthly_budget/skill_adherence-1

Behavior

Hark did not request the user's age during the initial budget intake. No retirement recommendation was created, and the interaction stopped at initial intake. Hark could collect age later if retirement planning becomes relevant, so the omission cannot yet be classified as harmful or needlessly delaying.

Turn 1

E0001User message
Build me a monthly budget
E0002Tool call: skillDispatch: toolu_014uQ9U9fQZpqGKoNFaSrMy9
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_014uQ9U9fQZpqGKoNFaSrMy9", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "load", "addendum_for": null, "content": null, "description": null, "find": null, "id": "_system/planning-budgets", "name": null, "replace": null, "scope": null}, "tool_name": "skill"}
E0003Tool result: skillDispatch: toolu_014uQ9U9fQZpqGKoNFaSrMy9Evidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_014uQ9U9fQZpqGKoNFaSrMy9", "elapsed": 0.00472017, "error": "", "result": {"address": "_system/planning-budgets", "content": "# Building a budget\n\nHow to handle a request to build a personal budget.\n\n## Before spinning up browser\n\n- Search emails and memory for checking, savings, credit card accounts, or financial documents.\n- Ask the user for relevant details on money that lands in accounts after taxes, and what any fixed expenses are (i.e., rent, mortgage, etc.)\n- If the user does not provide categories, let the user provide missing information. Do not include too many line items but include a minimum of 7 categories. A high schooler should be able to read and understand the budget.\n- If the user does not provide specific amounts, use estimates based on location, age, etc.\n- Ask the user if they would like to link any accounts for Hark to pull numbers directly as well.\n- Ask the user what their budgeting priorities (e.g., saving for something, paying down something).\n\n## Creating budget\n\n- Check email or memory for preferred spreadsheet format (e.g., Google Sheets, CSV, XLSX, etc.)\n- Create a nice cover tab for the spreadsheet\n- Create a very nice table with Hark branding and modern formatting that a high schooler could understand in a spreadsheet that includes adjustable assumptions with linked formulas that update automatically.\n- Make sure all inputs are in blue and linked formulas are in green.\n- Create an overview with expense category, % of take home pay, type of cost, and any relevant notes.\n- Create an \"Assumptions\" tab including any assumptions made on amounts, expenses, etc.\n- Create a \"Net Worth\" tab including any other cash, investments, etc.\n\n## Implementing budget\n\n- Apply the credit card promos skill.\n- Apply the cancelling subscriptions skill.\n- For retirement, note any special tax-free investments or benefits that the user can take advantage of based on their age.\n\nFollow these instructions as your guide. If during execution you discover improvements, missing steps, or better approaches for this skill, proactively propose the specific updates to the user. Use the skill tool's create/edit actions to save improvements.", "resolved_from": null, "success": true}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "skill"}
E0004Tool call: memoryDispatch: toolu_01E373XcmzkfMaRvumRJ4CL9
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01E373XcmzkfMaRvumRJ4CL9", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "search", "query": "budget income expenses rent salary finances"}, "tool_name": "memory"}
E0005Tool result: memoryDispatch: toolu_01E373XcmzkfMaRvumRJ4CL9
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01E373XcmzkfMaRvumRJ4CL9", "elapsed": 0.138866673, "error": "", "result": {"results": [{"citation": "seg://ebf480cb", "score": 0.6012, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to activate credit-card promotional offers. Hark asked the user to specify the card issuer, such as Amex, Chase, or Citi, and no activation was completed. Later that day, the user asked Hark to find a new fall wardrobe and build it as a shopping site. Hark requested preferences about menswear or womenswear, style direction, and budget per piece; no wardrobe or shopping site was created yet.", "source": "episode", "subject": "Credit Card Promos and Fall Wardrobe Requests", "summary": "The user requested credit-card promo activation and a fall wardrobe shopping site on September 4, 2026. Both requests remain pending additional details, and neither task was completed.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:04 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://139b3f9d", "score": 0.6, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the assistant delivered the user’s meal-planning questions as one confirmed message: how many days and people to plan for, which foods the recipient avoids or is allergic to, and whether the recipient has a daily protein target. The draft was polished into texting register, and the assistant finalized the run after no further reply was needed.", "source": "episode", "subject": "Meal-planning questions delivered", "summary": "The meal-planning intake questions were successfully delivered in polished texting form. The interaction was then marked complete.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:26 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://35c964ae", "confidence": "high", "score": 0.6, "segment_id": "35c964ae-dd25-5867-bc56-6174d8652b2d", "snippet": "The user is planning a Tokyo trip for September 11–13, 2026, spanning Friday through Sunday.", "source": "fact", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:07 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://8994f175", "score": 0.4668, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user requested a dinner reservation for five people in San Francisco on Tuesday, September 8, or Wednesday, September 9, 2026, considering Ernest, Cotogna, Rintaro, House of Prime Rib, and Zuni Cafe. Hark launched availability-only searches for all five restaurants and did not book anything. The completed Rintaro search found that Rintaro, at 82 14th Street, is closed Tuesday, September 8, and sold out for five on Wednesday, September 9; Resy offered a “Notify for Dinner” alert, and the next displayed availability was Sunday, September 20. Rintaro’s phone number is (415) 589-7022. Reservations generally open 28 days ahead at 10:00 a.m.; cancellations or re-bookings within 24 hours incur a $50-per-person fee, with no upfront deposit disclosed for standard parties of 1–8. Searches for Ernest, Cotogna, House of Prime Rib, and Zuni Cafe were still pending when the conversation ended.", "source": "episode", "subject": "San Francisco restaurant reservation search for September 8–9, 2026", "summary": "Hark checked reservation availability for a party of five at five San Francisco restaurants for September 8–9, 2026. Rintaro had no availability—closed Tuesday and sold out Wednesday, with a notification option—and no reservation was booked.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:14 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://25b045d2", "score": 0.4649, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user requested a high-protein meal plan with delivery from Walmart. Hark asked for the number of days and people, foods to avoid or allergies, daily protein target, and Walmart delivery address before proceeding. The questions were delivered as one confirmed message; no meal plan or Walmart order was completed.", "source": "episode", "subject": "High-Protein Walmart Meal Plan Intake", "summary": "The user’s Walmart meal-plan request remained at the intake stage pending planning details and delivery address.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:31 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://53493940", "score": 0.4309, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to book a doctor’s appointment; the appointment was not booked. The user also asked for Levi’s Stadium events in October and November 2026, and Hark identified six official-calendar events: Broncos vs. 49ers on October 4, Bruno Mars on October 10 and 11, Commanders vs. 49ers on October 19, Raiders vs. 49ers on November 8, and Seahawks vs. 49ers on November 29. The user then asked Hark to create a high-protein meal plan and arrange Walmart delivery; the task was started but not completed.", "source": "episode", "subject": "September 4, 2026 Requests: Doctor, Levi’s Stadium, and Walmart Meal Plan", "summary": "Hark completed the Levi’s Stadium event lookup for October–November 2026. The doctor appointment and Walmart high-protein meal-plan delivery requests remained incomplete.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 5:27 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://a2156275", "score": 0.4167, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked about dinner reservations for five people in San Francisco on Tuesday, September 8, and Wednesday, September 9, 2026. Cotogna had broad Tuesday availability from 5:00–9:00 PM, but only outdoor terrace seating; Wednesday was sold out. House of Prime Rib had only 10:00 PM Tuesday and 9:30 or 10:00 PM Wednesday. Ernest was closed Tuesday and had only a 5:30 PM Wednesday table in the main dining room. Rintaro was closed Tuesday and sold out Wednesday, with the next reported five-person availability on Sunday, September 20. Zuni did not accept online reservations for parties of five or more, requiring a call to (415) 552-2522. No reservation was booked. The user received a correction that Cotogna charges $50 per person for cancellations within 24 hours, Ernest charges $50 per person within 48 hours, and House of Prime Rib publishes no cancellation policy.", "source": "episode", "subject": "San Francisco dinner reservation search for five on September 8–9, 2026", "summary": "Cotogna Tuesday was the strongest option if outdoor dining was acceptable; Ernest Wednesday at 5:30 PM was the best indoor alternative. No booking was made.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:18 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}]}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "memory"}
E0006Tool call: send_messageDispatch: toolu_01UZF3iDzGwxkUmpnAx3p1b1
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01UZF3iDzGwxkUmpnAx3p1b1", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"final": true, "message": "Happy to. A few things so the numbers are yours, not generic:\n\n1. Monthly take-home pay (after taxes), and anyone else's income in the household?\n2. Fixed costs: rent/mortgage, car, insurance, debt payments?\n3. City you're in, and any savings goal you're aiming at (house, travel, paying down debt)?\n4. Want me to scan your Gmail for statements to pull real numbers, and do you prefer Google Sheets or Excel?\n\nIf you'd rather not dig, give me take-home pay and rent and I'll estimate the rest for your area."}, "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0007Tool result: send_messageDispatch: toolu_01UZF3iDzGwxkUmpnAx3p1b1
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01UZF3iDzGwxkUmpnAx3p1b1", "elapsed": 4.638058043, "error": "", "result": "Delivered (confirmed) as 2 messages. Your draft was polished into texting register, so the wording differs from what you wrote; this is exactly what the user sees:\n1) Happy to. Send me your monthly take-home pay, rent or mortgage, car and insurance costs, debt payments, city, and savings goal.\n2) If you’d rather keep it simple, give me your take-home pay and rent, and I’ll estimate the rest for your area. Do you want Google Sheets or Excel?\nThese are your words now, and this is the whole reply: the delivery layer chose its density and shape by design. Never dispute, re-explain, or apologize for the phrasing, and never send a supplement to restore detail it left out. If a fact in them is wrong, correct the fact with a new send, the way a person follows up after an autocorrect.\n\nYour turn continues.\nanswers: 24fd69de-177b-4405-9283-c3c45af90692", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0008Assistant messageEvidence cited by the judge
Happy to. Send me your monthly take-home pay, rent or mortgage, car and insurance costs, debt payments, city, and savings goal.
E0009Assistant messageEvidence cited by the judge
If you’d rather keep it simple, give me your take-home pay and rent, and I’ll estimate the rest for your area. Do you want Google Sheets or Excel?

launch25/nvidia_q2_slide_deck/skill_adherence-3

Behavior

Hark truncated the deck validation output with `tail -20`, so the recorded evidence omitted the validator's explicit overall status before delivery. The omission is observable, but the command completed and the visible fragment shows empty issue arrays. Because the pipeline did not preserve an explicit `ok: true` or reliably expose the validator's exit status, the evidence establishes neither successful validation nor a validation failure.

Turn 1

E0001User message
Turn NVIDIA's Q2 report into a slide deck
E0002Tool call: skillDispatch: toolu_01SA7ZkzBUpwyYUXQD3SwUhX
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01SA7ZkzBUpwyYUXQD3SwUhX", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "load", "addendum_for": null, "content": null, "description": null, "find": null, "id": "_system/build-deck", "name": null, "replace": null, "scope": null}, "tool_name": "skill"}
E0003Tool result: skillDispatch: toolu_01SA7ZkzBUpwyYUXQD3SwUhX
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01SA7ZkzBUpwyYUXQD3SwUhX", "elapsed": 0.005445867, "error": "", "result": {"address": "_system/build-deck", "content": "# Build a deck\n\nDecide the argument, write it as a spec, and let `deckbuild` lay it out:\n\n```\ndeck.json ──deckbuild──▶ deck.pptx editable native deck (PowerPoint, Slides, Keynote)\n ▶ deck.html preview, identical geometry\n │\n ┌─────────┴─────────┐\n Drive upload OneDrive upload\n (converts to Slides) (opens in PowerPoint)\n```\n\nYour job is the argument and the content. The template owns every position, size,\nand type choice, which is what makes a deck look composed rather than assembled. Backgrounds and chrome — washes, corner fields, column rules, numeral chips — are\ngenerated per slide from the palette. Do not reach for pandoc: its slide output has one content box per slide and cannot express these layouts.\n\n`deckbuild` refuses to write a deck whose text collides, leaves the safe margin,\nor overflows. A non-zero exit is a content problem to fix, not an error to work around.\n\n## Step 1 — Pick a template\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild templates\n```\n\n| Template | The kind of deck it is for |\n| ------------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------- |\n| `editorial` | Analysis and internal writing where the argument carries the deck: reviews, post-mortems, recommendations, memos. Serif, essayistic. |\n| `board` | Work that gets decided on: board papers, strategic assessments, equity research, diligence. Dense, numeric, rules instead of colour. |\n| `pitch` | Selling something: fundraising, launches, keynotes, proposals. Sparse, one claim per slide, very large stat numerals. |\n| `feature` | Narrative and brand work where pictures do the arguing: stories, campaigns, product tours. Display type over imagery. |\n| `dossier` | Profiles, bios, team context, and people briefs. Portrait-led, with facts immediately below the name and narrative underneath. |\n| `briefing` | Pre-meeting context, handoffs, blockers, and operating briefs. Answer-first, with ruled status rows and explicit next actions. |\n| `field-notes` | Scouting reports, observations, site visits, and informal profiles. Tactile paper, large type, and offset image treatments. |\n| `studio` | Project decks, portfolios, and creative reviews. Oversized type, multiple image roles, motifs, and changing silhouettes. |\n| `signal` | Provocations, launches, and high-energy keynotes. Oversized condensed type, blunt colour fields, and one soft halo. |\n| `organic` | Purpose, sustainability, place, and wellness. Curved fields, bright natural accents, and framed image windows. |\n| `atlas` | Travel, place, culture, and expedition work. Tracked capitals over 14pt body copy, alternating slate and paper grounds, and a recurring flight of marks. |\n| `bold` | Campaigns, manifestos, launches, and public proposals with a clear point of view. Poster type, hard crops, and alternating fields. |\n| `desk` | Numbers-forward reporting read on a screen: coverage notes, monthly reviews, diligence memos. Near-black ground, tiled cards, one electric accent. |\n| `guideline` | A standard someone has to follow: brand guidelines, design systems, editorial rules. Paper white, ruled pairs, and the system shown as itself. |\n\nPick by what the deck is _for_, not by subject. A revenue review is `editorial`; the same numbers going to a board is `board`; the same company raising money is\n`pitch`. Default to `editorial` when it is genuinely ambiguous, and say which you picked and why.\n\nEach template carries its own palette and typography, so a spec with no `theme` already looks composed.\n\nThe template also fixes two things about how the deck is written, because they follow from what it is for rather than being separate choices:\n\n| Template | Spine | The deck moves by | Titles |\n| ------------------------------------------------- | ----------- | -------------------------------------------------------- | -------- |\n| `board` `editorial` `briefing` | `pyramid` | Answer first, then the support that earns it | `action` |\n| `pitch` | `sparkline` | Alternating what is with what could be, ending on reward | `label` |\n| `feature` `dossier` `field-notes` `studio` `bold` | `thread` | One line followed — through time, place, or theme | `label` |\n\n`deckbuild outline` reports both, so there is nothing to remember.\n\n## Step 2 — Write the outline first\n\n**Write the whole deck as titles before writing a word of content.** One line per slide: layout and title, no real bodies, bullets, or images. Add only the parser stubs a layout requires (`\"items\":[{\"body\":\"TBD\"}]` or `\"image\":\"TBD.png\"`); `outline` ignores them.\nConsultants call this a ghost deck, and skipping it is the single largest source of a deck that reads as a pile of true statements rather than an argument.\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild outline deck.json\n```\n\nIt prints the deck as its titles alone and reports what it can count. Then apply\nthe test the printout exists for:\n\n> **Read only the titles, top to bottom. Do they carry the argument to the\n> recommendation, with no body copy at all?**\n\nIf a title can be deleted without the argument losing a step, that slide has no\njob. If two consecutive titles do not connect — no _therefore_, no _but_, no\n_which is why_ — a step is missing between them. If the last title is not what\nshould happen next, the deck stops rather than concludes.\n\nRevise the titles until the spine reads. Only then fill in bodies.\n\n**A `section` divider states its section's conclusion, not its subject.** This is\nwhere a spine most often dies. `\"Where Boeing wins and where it doesn't\"` is an\nagenda item; `\"Boeing wins widebody and loses narrowbody\"` is the same slide\ncarrying its share of the argument. In an `action` deck a title that opens on\n_what_, _who_, _where_, _why_, _how_ or _when_ is a question fragment and cannot\nbe a finding — `deckbuild outline` flags those, because that much is grammar\nrather than judgement. A `label` deck is free to use them: `\"What changed\"` is a\nfine label.\n\n## Step 3 — Write deck.json\n\nStart from a working spec rather than from memory:\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild example editorial > deck.json\n```\n\nThe shape:\n\n```json\n{\n \"title\": \"Q3 Business Review\",\n \"template\": \"editorial\",\n \"theme\": {\n \"ground\": \"#FBF8F1\",\n \"ink\": \"#0F1512\",\n \"accent\": \"#9A3412\"\n },\n \"brand\": { \"name\": \"Hark\", \"site\": \"hark.com\" },\n \"slides\": [{ \"layout\": \"title\", \"title\": \"Retention is the constraint on growth this quarter\" }]\n}\n```\n\nThree colors and one or two faces. A wider palette is how a deck starts looking\ngenerated. `muted` is derived from `ink` and `ground` unless you set it, and\n`inverse` is the text color used over a dark image or a filled section band.\n\nSeventy-six named palettes ship with deckbuild, each suited to several templates.\nTwenty-two have a dark ground, so a deck read on a screen is a choice rather than an\naccident of which template you picked:\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild palettes # all of them\ndeckbuild palettes board # the ones suited to a template\n```\n\n`deckbuild palettes <template>` is the full list; the table below is a starting\npoint for when the command is unavailable. Pick by the subject's mood; palette is\nthe visual choice that most distinguishes two decks built from one template, and a\ntemplate's first-listed palette is not its default so much as its most obvious.\n\n| Template | Paper grounds | Dark grounds | All |\n| ------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------ | -------------------------------- | --- |\n| `editorial` | `parchment`, `ledger`, `sage`, `newsprint` | `nocturne`, `shale`, `galley` | 15 |\n| `board` | `ledger`, `institutional`, `graphite`, `forest` | `carbon`, `bluechip`, `meridian` | 14 |\n| `pitch` | `graphite`, `signal`, `ultraviolet`, `mint` | `carbon`, `ember`, `flare` | 10 |\n| `feature` | `grove`, `sand`, `tide`, `atlas` | `nocturne`, `petrol`, `ember` | 16 |\n| `dossier` | `parchment`, `ledger`, `sage`, `cobalt-paper` | `nocturne`, `library`, `petrol` | 15 |\n| `briefing` | `institutional`, `graphite`, `memo`, `minute` | `carbon`, `library`, `quorum` | 12 |\n| `field-notes` | `sage`, `cobalt-paper`, `grove`, `haar` | `ember`, `dusk`, `peat` | 15 |\n| `studio` | `parchment`, `cyanotype`, `sand`, `paper-ink` | `basalt`, `darkroom` | 11 |\n| `atlas` | `grove`, `sand`, `tide`, `atlas` | `dusk`, `basalt` | 8 |\n| `signal` | `ultraviolet`, `vermilion`, `hi-vis` | `ember`, `flare`, `riptide` | 7 |\n| `organic` | `sage`, `mint`, `canopy`, `quarry` | `peat`, `understory` | 10 |\n| `bold` | `cobalt-cream`, `vermilion-paper`, `acid-ink`, `violet-milk` | `riptide`, `nettle`, `velvet` | 11 |\n| `desk` | `graphite`, `pewter` | `carbon`, `bluechip`, `meridian` | 8 |\n| `guideline` | `ledger`, `newsprint`, `clay`, `bond` | `shale` | 10 |\n\nName one with `\"palette\": \"graphite\"` and leave `theme` out. Pick by the subject's mood, not by habit; palette is one of the visual choices that distinguishes decks built from the same template. Say which you chose.\n\nUse `theme` only to apply a brand colour on top: `\"palette\": \"signal\"` with\n`\"theme\": {\"accent\": \"#D4623A\"}` keeps the palette and replaces one value.\n\nSeventeen palettes declare a fifth `spot` colour: one rare signal for a mark that\nhas to interrupt rather than harmonise, used by the `atlas_field` treatment and\nby directional marks. The other fifty-nine leave it unset and those marks fall\nback to the accent. Do not add a `spot` to a palette that has none, since a spot every\npalette carries is not a spot.\n\n### Choose a treatment when the composition needs a different voice\n\nThe template fixes the content geometry; `treatment` fixes the recurring\nbackground and chrome. Omit it, or set `\"treatment\": \"auto\"`, for a stable\nautomatic choice. Name one when the visual direction matters:\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild treatments dossier\ndeckbuild treatments briefing\n```\n\n```json\n{ \"template\": \"dossier\", \"palette\": \"cobalt-paper\", \"treatment\": \"archive_spine\" }\n```\n\nTreatments are template-specific by design. `dossier` offers `archive_spine`,\n`folio_frame`, and `paper_wash`; `briefing` offers `memo_split`, `status_rail`,\nand `decision_bar`; `bold` offers `edge_band`, `base_bar`, and `corner_rules`.\nA treatment from another template is rejected instead of quietly making two\ntemplates converge.\n\nThe controllable visual axes are: `template` for structure, `typography` for a\ncurated font system, `treatment` for recurring composition, `palette` for color,\n`theme` for exact brand overrides, and image `placement` plus cadence for visual\nemphasis.\n\nFor `bold`, read [`references/bold.md`](references/bold.md) before writing. It\ndefines the pacing, image direction, title register, and cases where bold is the\nwrong choice.\n\n**Typography.** Prefer a named `typography` system over manual font names. Run\n`deckbuild typography`, then read [`references/typography.md`](references/typography.md).\nIt defines the sans/serif/display roles, curated pairings, and misuse warnings.\nEvery named system uses bundled OFL faces that PowerPoint embeds. Exact\n`theme.heading` or `theme.body` values remain available for a real brand font;\nthey override the preset and are checked against the same role rules.\n\n### Layouts — choose by the shape of the content\n\nDecide what a slide has to do, then take the layout that does it. Reaching for\n`bullets` every time is what makes a deck look generated; a deck that varies\nbecause its content varies is the thing to aim for. Every layout works in every\ntemplate.\n\n| `layout` | Reach for it when | Needs |\n| ----------- | -------------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------- |\n| `title` | Opening. The title states the thesis, not the topic. | `title` |\n| `contents` | The deck is long enough that the audience wants a map. Six items at most. | `items` |\n| `section` | The argument turns. One every four to six slides, numbered in `eyebrow`. | `title` |\n| `statement` | One sentence is the whole point of the slide and deserves the room. | `title` |\n| `bullets` | Genuinely a list of peers with nothing to compare across. Rarer than you think. | `title`, `bullets` |\n| `numbered` | Order or sequence matters: steps, ranked options, things tried in turn. | `title`, `items` |\n| `columns` | Two or three things held against each other: before/after, us/them, risk/reward. | `title`, `items` |\n| `metrics` | Two to four numbers carry the point. One number alone is a `statement`. | `items[].value` |\n| `table` | Two dimensions — things down the side, attributes across the top. | `columns`, `rows` |\n| `quote` | Someone else's words are better evidence than your summary. | `quote` |\n| `image` | A picture argues better than a sentence. Never decoration. | `title`, `image` |\n| `triptych` | A full-height image separates observations from a short narrative. | `title`, `image`, `items` |\n| `gallery` | Two to four images are peers, or a stacked pair carries the page. | `items[].image` |\n| `team` | Portraits, names, and roles should read as one visual roster. | `items[].image` |\n| `timeline` | Milestones need a visible temporal line rather than numbered prose. | `items` |\n| `chart` | A rendered chart is evidence beside editable interpretation. | `title`, `image` |\n| `bars` | A set of magnitudes should be compared by length rather than read as numerals. | `title`, `items[].amount` |\n| `closing` | The ask: a decision, an owner, a date. | `title` |\n\nFour further recipes are compositions taken from professionally produced decks.\nRead [`references/compositions.md`](references/compositions.md) before using one.\n\n| `layout` | Reach for it when | Needs |\n| ------------------- | ----------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------- |\n| `editorial-collage` | Two or three frames argue with each other rather than illustrating one claim. | `title`, `items[].image` |\n| `portrait-strip` | Two or three tall crops are peers and each needs its own caption. | `title`, `items[].image` |\n| `panorama-sidebar` | One wide frame carries the scale and a rail explains it. | `title`, `image`, `items` |\n| `hero-proof` | One claim over a darkened image, with numbered proof beneath it. | `title`, `image`, `items` |\n\nTwo more document a design system rather than argue a case, and are what\n`guideline` exists for.\n\n| `layout` | Reach for it when | Needs |\n| ---------- | ---------------------------------------------------------------------------- | ------------------------ |\n| `swatches` | The palette is the content: each colour named, described, and printed. | `title`, `items[].value` |\n| `specimen` | The typography is the content, set in the deck's own faces at its own sizes. | `title` |\n\nReading the same content three ways, so the choice is deliberate:\n\n- \"June 61%, July 48%, August 46%\" across three cohorts and three days is a\n `table` — two dimensions.\n- \"Day-7 retention 61% → 48%, alongside NRR and churn\" is `metrics` — several\n numbers, each with its comparison in the item's `body`.\n- \"Retention is the constraint\" is a `statement`, with the evidence on the slide\n after it.\n\nOptional fields: `subtitle` and `eyebrow` on a `title`; `eyebrow` as the section\nnumber; `body` as a lead line under a `section`, `statement`, or `closing`;\n`items` as a fact row on `title` and `closing`; `attribution` on a `quote`;\n`placement` on an `image`. Every slide takes `notes`.\n\n`items` entries are `{heading, body, value, image, image_prompt, amount}`, or a bare string meaning `body`.\n`placement` is `left`, `right` (half-bleed column, text alongside), `full`, or\n`bleed` (behind the text, which is darkened for contrast).\n\nOn a `full` or `bleed` image, `scrim` decides how the copy is made readable.\n`full`, the default, darkens the whole canvas and is right when the claim is the\nsubject. `card` lays a near-solid panel in the ground colour under the copy alone\nand leaves the rest of the photograph untouched, which is what a brand page does.\nThe five templates that compose their own full-bleed image — `bold`, `dossier`,\n`field-notes`, `organic`, `signal` — take `full` only, and asking for a card there\nis refused rather than dropped.\n\n`bars` takes an `amount` on every item: a non-negative number in whatever unit\nthe slide is about, which sets each bar's length against the largest in the set.\nPut the formatted figure in `value` and the label in `heading`, and the numerals\nstay editable text rather than becoming part of a picture.\n\n`swatches` takes a colour in each item's `value`, with `heading` as its name and\n`body` as the rule for using it. The hex is printed inside the chip.\n\nAny slide may also carry `cutout` (a transparent foreground figure, on `studio`,\n`bold`, and `feature`), `motif` (`studio` only), and `directional_mark`. Their\nanchors and knobs are in\n[`references/compositions.md`](references/compositions.md). A knob set without\nthe asset it configures is rejected rather than ignored.\n\nIn `briefing`, `numbered` becomes a ruled status or action sequence: put the\nshort marker, owner, or date in `heading` and the update in `body`. Its `title`\nand `closing` item rows are the place for decision, owner, date, and status.\n\n### Vary the deck\n\nA deck where every slide is the same shape is a worse deck, whatever the content.\nTwo rules that fall out of that:\n\n- **No layout three times in a row.** If three consecutive slides want `columns`,\n one of them is really a `table` or a `statement`.\n- **A `section` earns its place** by changing the subject, not by punctuating a\n list.\n\n### Facts\n\nSearch before writing any number, price, date, or name you would otherwise be\nrecalling. A deck of plausible-looking figures nobody checked is worse than one\nwith fewer figures, because it will be presented as if it were true.\n\nPut the source in the slide's `notes` — where the number came from and as of\nwhen. A board asking \"says who?\" is the normal case, not the awkward one.\n\nWhere a figure cannot be verified, say so on the slide rather than dropping it\nsilently: \"internal estimate\" and \"as reported, Q2\" are both fine; an unsourced\nnumber that looks sourced is not.\n\n## Step 4 — Content discipline\n\nThis is what separates a deck someone presents from a wall of text with a title.\nApply it while writing the spec, not as a cleanup pass.\n\n**Titles come in two registers and a deck commits to one.** The template picks\nit; writing in between is what produces a claim with the substance squeezed out.\n\nAn **action** title _is_ the finding, stated in full — 6 to 16 words, 4 to 10 for\na divider:\n\n> `\"Cash is still burned turning the backlog into deliveries\"`\n> `\"Consensus has already priced in most of the recovery\"`\n\nNot `\"Cash flow\"`, which says nothing, and not `\"The moat is real and\nstructural\"`, which asserts something without saying what it is. Published\nconsulting headlines run this long for a reason: the qualifier is the finding.\n\nA **label** title names the moment and lets the slide argue — 1 to 5 words, 1 to\n4 for a divider:\n\n> `\"The problem\"` `\"What changed\"` `\"Kurama in the rain\"`\n\nHere the picture or the single number carries the weight, and a full sentence\nacross the top fights it.\n\n**No commas in a title.** A comma is where a second thought gets appended to the\nfirst, and it leaves two half-claims where one whole one would land harder:\n`\"Right on Mathilda, no commute at all\"` is really `\"The commute is a five-minute\nwalk\"`. Rewrite until the point survives as one clause — if it will not, the\ntitle is carrying two ideas and the second one belongs on its own slide, or in\nthe body. Only a `quote` keeps its commas, being someone else's words.\n\nThe same goes for a semicolon or a dash joining two independent clauses: a\nsentence wearing a heading's clothes. Headings take no full stop; a `statement`\nslide is the exception, because it _is_ a sentence.\n\nTitle budgets `deckbuild outline` reports:\n\n| Register | Slide title | Section divider |\n| -------- | ----------- | --------------- |\n| `action` | 6–16 words | 4–10 words |\n| `label` | 1–5 words | 1–4 words |\n\nAnd for the copy underneath: a bullet is at most 14 words, an item body or a\nlead line at most 24. Past that it is prose, and prose belongs in `notes`.\n\n**One idea per slide.** Two ideas means two slides. Slides are free.\n\n**Numbers get context.** `NRR fell to 96%` invites \"from what, against what\nplan?\". Give the comparison in the same line: `NRR 112% → 96%, plan 105%`. A\ncount without a denominator is not evidence.\n\n**Use `metrics` for headline numbers and `table` for two dimensions.** A bulleted\nlist of \"June: 61%, July: 48%\" is a table someone forgot to draw.\n\n**Prose belongs in `notes`.** If a slide needs a paragraph to make sense, the\nparagraph is a speaker note and the slide keeps the assertion. Write notes for\nevery slide that makes a claim — they cost the reader nothing and let someone\nelse present the deck.\n\n**A `section` every four to six content slides.** It gives the audience a place\nto breathe and the presenter a place to check the room. A deck under eight\nslides may skip dividers when its arc is already obvious; do not spend one-sixth\nof a six-slide briefing announcing that it has reached the middle.\n\n**End on the ask.** The `closing` slide is what should happen next: a decision,\nan owner, a date. Not \"Thank you\", not \"Questions?\".\n\nWhen the user hands over source material, read it first, decide the argument,\nthen write slides that make that argument. Do not walk the source top to bottom\nturning each section into a slide.\n\n## Step 5 — Images\n\n`generate_image` writes a `.png` into the working directory and returns its path.\nReference it by filename in the spec:\n\n```json\n{\n \"layout\": \"image\",\n \"title\": \"Sign-in is where automation dies\",\n \"body\": \"Every useful task sits behind a login.\",\n \"image\": \"hero.png\",\n \"placement\": \"right\"\n}\n```\n\n**Ask the deck what shape each region is; do not guess.** Write the spec with\nevery `image` and `image_prompt` filled in first, then:\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild images deck.json # add --json for the same plan machine-readable\n```\n\nIt lists every picture the layouts place, the orientation and pixel size of the\nregion each one fills, and the prompt already recorded for it:\n\n```\nMAKE hero.png landscape 1920x1080 slide 2\n A harbour at first light, documentary photograph, muted\nMAKE frame-1.png portrait 904x1920 slide 6\n A weathered lighthouse tower against low cloud\n```\n\nGenerate exactly that list at those sizes, then build. deckbuild crops to fill\nwithout distorting, so an image the wrong shape loses the difference off its\nsides, taken from the centre where the subject usually is. The regions are not\nguessable: a `portrait-strip` frame is 0.47:1, far narrower than the 2:3 a\ngenerator returns by default, and a `panorama-sidebar` frame is wider than any\npreset.\n\nA row marked `(uncropped: keep the subject whole)` is a cutout — placed whole\nrather than filled to its box, so its own framing is what shows.\n\nPrompt for photographic, uncluttered images with room for text — a subject to one\nside, or an even texture. A busy image under a title fights it. Record what you\nasked for in `image_prompt` so the choice is legible later.\n\n**How many is a property of the template, not a matter of taste.** Some\ntemplates argue with pictures and look unfinished without them; others do the\nwork with rules and numbers and look padded with them. Never reuse the same\nimage on two slides.\n\n| Template | Imagery |\n| --------------------------------------------- | ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ |\n| `feature`, `atlas`, `studio` | Image-led. Most slides carry one; a run of three type-only slides means the deck is under-illustrated. |\n| `bold`, `field-notes`, `organic` | One decisive anchor about every third slide, alternating with type-led pages. |\n| `pitch`, `signal`, `desk`, `dossier` | One or two anchors in the whole deck. The numerals and fields carry the rest. |\n| `editorial`, `board`, `briefing`, `guideline` | Only where the picture is evidence. These decks are complete with none. |\n\nReach that count by using the layouts that place several frames at once —\n`gallery`, `triptych`, `portrait-strip`, `editorial-collage` — rather than by\nrepeating single `image` slides.\n\n- `dossier`: prefer one verified portrait or supplied photo. Never generate a\n likeness of a real colleague; use a generated portrait only for a fictional\n example, and use an object, place, or abstract cutout when no real photo exists.\n- `briefing`: add an image only when it is evidence or meeting context. Its rules,\n owner fields, dates, and status rows already do the visual work.\n- `field-notes`: bias toward one or two isolated objects, cutouts, or candid\n photographs with deliberate negative space. A transparent or paper-coloured\n background makes the offset frame feel intentional.\n- `feature`: images carry the thread; vary portraits, wide scenes, and details.\n- `bold`: use one decisive documentary or rendered anchor about every three\n slides; alternate it with quiet type-led pages instead of decorating every page.\n\nGenerated visuals can also be diagrammatic or rendered as SVG when a real image\nwould imply false evidence. Do not generate fake screenshots, logos, documents,\nor photographs of real events. Prompt the subject's side and crop explicitly,\nand keep `image_prompt` on every slide that names an image.\n\nA missing file is a warning, not a failure: the deck still builds with the\nregion reserved, so a generation that fails does not block delivery. Run\n`deckbuild images deck.json` again at the end — anything still marked `MAKE` is\na hole in the finished deck.\n\nFor a supplied reference `.pptx`, follow\n[`references/reference-audit.md`](references/reference-audit.md): measure every\nslide, map recurring patterns to semantic layouts, reconstruct, then compare.\n\n## Step 6 — Build\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild build deck.json\n```\n\nWrites `deck.pptx` and `deck.html`. `build` writes both by default; keep it that way: the preview is how\nthe deck gets looked at before anyone opens PowerPoint.\n\nWhen it refuses, it names the slide, the element, and the fix:\n\n```\nslide 4: text_outside_safe — slide4.body at 0.72,5.10 5.80×2.31 leaves the safe\n area (0.72,0.72 11.89×6.06) — runs 0.55 in past the bottom; cut about 34 words\n```\n\n| Error | What it means |\n| ------------------- | --------------------------------------------------------------- |\n| `text_outside_safe` | Too much copy for the slide. Cut it, or split into two slides. |\n| `text_overlap` | Two text blocks collide. Almost always too many `items`. |\n| `occluded_text` | Something is painted over text. A template bug — report it. |\n| `text_overflow` | A fixed box, usually a table cell, holds more than it can show. |\n| `low_contrast` | Text too close in tone to what is behind it. |\n| `furniture_wraps` | A brand or page mark ran to a second line. A template bug. |\n| `image_offcanvas` | An image region falls outside the slide. A template bug. |\n\nA failure prefixed `[keynote]`, `[google-slides]` or `[powerpoint]` happens only\nin that application: the deck is sound at authoring size and breaks under that\none's transform. Fix it the same way — the geometry has to survive all three.\n\nCut words rather than fighting the layout. The word count is measured from the\nline fitting, not guessed.\n\nTo look at a refusal instead of fixing it blind:\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild build deck.json --debug-boxes --force \\\n --pptx deck.debug.pptx --html deck.debug.html\n```\n\nThat outlines every element by kind and draws the collision in red. Use it to\nunderstand a failure; never ship the `--force` output.\n\n## Step 7 — Verify\n\n```bash\ndeckbuild check deck.json # geometry, consumers, fonts, style, storyline\ndeckbuild outline deck.json # the spine, one last time\n```\n\n`check` exits 0 with `\"ok\": true` when the deck is sound. Then run the outline\nonce more and read the spine as a reader would — the bodies have changed since\nStep 2, and a title that drifted away from the slide beneath it is the usual\nresult. If the titles no longer carry the argument on their own, the deck is not\nfinished, and the fix is the titles rather than the bullets.\n\n## Step 8 — Deliver\n\nAsk where it should land only when the user has not implied it. \"Put it in my\nDrive\" and \"send it to Priya\" are answers; \"make me a deck\" is not, and the file\nis a fine default.\n\n**Google Drive, as a native Slides deck.** A `.pptx` uploaded with the Slides\nMIME type is converted on the way in, so the user gets a real Google Slides\npresentation. This needs only the Drive scope the `google` connector already\nholds, and the gateway injects the header for `googleapis.com`.\n\n```bash\ncurl -s -X POST \\\n 'https://www.googleapis.com/upload/drive/v3/files?uploadType=%5BREDACTED%5D&fields=%5BREDACTED%5D' \\\n -F \"metadata={\\\"name\\\":\\\"Q3 Revenue Review\\\",\\\"mimeType\\\":\\\"application/vnd.google-apps.presentation\\\"};type=application/json\" \\\n -F \"file=@deck.pptx;type=application/vnd.openxmlformats-officedocument.presentationml.presentation\"\n```\n\nDrop `mimeType` to leave it an uploaded `.pptx`. Add `\"parents\":[\"FOLDER_ID\"]` to\nplace it. Hand the user the `webViewLink`, never a raw id.\n\n**OneDrive or SharePoint.** `.pptx` is native, no conversion. Load\n`microsoft-files` for the conventions.\n\n```bash\ncurl -s -X PUT \\\n 'https://graph.microsoft.com/v1.0/me/drive/root:/Decks/Q3 Review.pptx:/content' \\\n -H 'Content-Type: application/octet-stream' \\\n --data-binary @deck.pptx\n```\n\nOver 4 MB needs a Graph upload session — a deck with several photographs will\ncross that. Say so rather than sending a truncated file.\n\n**Keynote** imports `.pptx` directly. Hand over the file.\n\n**Email or chat** — attach `deck.pptx`. Load the relevant send skill.\n\nDo not upload anywhere the user did not ask for. A deck in the wrong Drive is a\ndeck they have to go delete.\n\n## Scope\n\nThis skill owns deck files and their delivery. When the user wants an interactive\nslideshow living inside the conversation as a web artifact rather than a file they\ncan edit, `build-slideshow` builds that instead.\n\nFollow these instructions as your guide. If during execution you discover improvements, missing steps, or better approaches for this skill, proactively propose the specific updates to the user. Use the skill tool's create/edit actions to save improvements.", "resolved_from": null, "success": true}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "skill"}
E0004Tool call: memoryDispatch: toolu_01Dr7HPbw87enqitTu7xhZ1X
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01Dr7HPbw87enqitTu7xhZ1X", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"action": "search", "query": "deck preferences slides style NVIDIA investing"}, "tool_name": "memory"}
E0005Tool result: memoryDispatch: toolu_01Dr7HPbw87enqitTu7xhZ1X
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01Dr7HPbw87enqitTu7xhZ1X", "elapsed": 0.139968975, "error": "", "result": {"results": [{"citation": "seg://8100bc0c", "score": 0.8364, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the assistant created and delivered a 13-slide board-style PowerPoint analyzing NVIDIA’s Q2 FY2027 results for the quarter ended July 26, 2026, reported August 26, 2026. The deck used the board template and forest palette, with sourced speaker notes, and covered $96.2B revenue (+106% year over year), $89.0B Data Center revenue (+117%), 75.0% gross margin, $2.22 non-GAAP EPS, and Q3 guidance of $108.0B revenue at 74.0% gross margin with no China Data Center compute revenue assumed. The deck also highlighted concentration risk and cash-conversion pressure: receivables of $63.1B, inventory of $31.6B, and Q2 free cash flow of $21.3B versus $48.6B in Q1. The initial build failed because the balance-sheet numbered slide had text overflow; the assistant shortened the copy, changed that slide to a columns layout, rebuilt successfully, passed all PowerPoint, Keynote, and Google Slides checks with no warnings, and uploaded the completed deck for the user.", "source": "episode", "subject": "NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 Board Deck Completed", "summary": "A validated 13-slide NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 board deck was delivered, emphasizing exceptional growth alongside Data Center concentration and working-capital pressure. The final PowerPoint passed compatibility checks and was uploaded successfully.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:17 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://41af1fd9", "score": 0.7998, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the user asked Hark to book a New York hotel for the following weekend. Hark resolved the dates to September 11–13, 2026, then asked whether check-in should be Friday or Saturday, along with the number of guests, nightly budget, and preferred neighborhood; no hotel was selected or booked. The user also asked Hark to turn NVIDIA’s Q2 FY2027 report into a slide deck. Hark retrieved NVIDIA’s official August 26, 2026 results for the quarter ended July 26, 2026, including $96.2 billion revenue, $89.0 billion Data Center revenue, 75.0% gross margin, $2.22 non-GAAP diluted EPS, and $108.0 billion Q3 revenue guidance. Hark chose a board-format deck with the Meridian palette, drafted a 14-slide outline, and began building `/workspace/nvda-q2-deck/deck.json`, but the build remained incomplete after deck validation flagged a missing heading or value for a bar-chart item; no finished deck was delivered.", "source": "episode", "subject": "New York Hotel Request and NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 Deck", "summary": "The New York hotel request remained pending clarification for September 11–13, 2026, with no booking made. Hark researched NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 results and started a board-style slide deck, but the deck was not completed or delivered.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:14 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://ceda8ace", "score": 0.7837, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the Assistant completed a 14-slide NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 earnings deck after fixing a layout error by reducing a numbered slide from five items to four. Validation passed with no errors, warnings, missing images, geometry issues, or font substitutions. The deck presents $96.2B revenue (+106% year over year), 75.0% gross margin, $89.0B Data Center revenue representing 92% of total revenue, weaker free-cash-flow conversion at $21.3B versus $48.6B in Q1, $22.3B growth in receivables, and Q3 guidance of $108B with China Data Center revenue assumed at zero. The editable PowerPoint and HTML preview were uploaded and delivered, using a dark “meridian” board template with figures sourced in speaker notes.", "source": "episode", "subject": "NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 earnings deck delivered", "summary": "The Assistant delivered a validated, editable 14-slide NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 earnings deck and HTML preview on September 4, 2026. The central message was strong revenue and guidance growth alongside weaker cash conversion and zero-China assumptions.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 6:18 PM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://1f3a0aa5", "confidence": "high", "score": 0.6, "segment_id": "1f3a0aa5-db7b-5f53-ab19-d7f76a8084a4", "snippet": "The user is planning a one-way nonstop flight from SFO (San Francisco) to JFK (New York) on December 17, 2026, and wants the cheapest available option.", "source": "fact", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:04 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}, {"citation": "seg://e4634264", "score": 0.3974, "snippet": "On September 4, 2026, the assistant researched nonstop one-way economy flights from SFO to JFK for one adult on Thursday, December 17, 2026. The cheapest option was American AA 148 for $250, departing at 4:01 PM and arriving at 12:30 AM on December 18; the fare included one carry-on and no checked bag, was not explicitly labeled Basic Economy, and was flagged as often delayed. Other lowest-priced options were JetBlue B6 16 at $261, Alaska AS 32 at $293, American AA 166 at $364, and Delta DL 363 at $364; nothing was booked. The assistant then found six official Levi’s Stadium events for October and November 2026: Broncos–49ers on October 4, Bruno Mars on October 10 and 11, Commanders–49ers on October 19, Raiders–49ers on November 8, and Seahawks–49ers on November 29. Later, the user asked the assistant to turn NVIDIA’s Q2 FY2027 report into a slide deck. The assistant reviewed the deck-building requirements, searched for NVIDIA’s official results, and retrieved the August 26, 2026 report showing $96.2 billion revenue, $89.0 billion Data Center revenue, 75.0% gross margin, $2.22 non-GAAP diluted EPS, and Q3 revenue guidance of $108.0 billion; no completed deck was delivered in the recorded exchange.", "source": "episode", "subject": "Flight research, Levi’s Stadium events, and NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 deck", "summary": "The assistant completed flight research and an official Levi’s Stadium event lookup, with no purchase or booking made. The assistant began preparing an NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 slide deck after retrieving the official report and key financial figures, but the deck was not completed in the recorded conversation.", "timestamp": "2026-09-04 10:09 AM PDT (UTC-07:00)"}]}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "memory"}
E0006Tool call: shellDispatch: toolu_01BPNruk4LiHKvxn61vYPQFf
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01BPNruk4LiHKvxn61vYPQFf", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "shell", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"command": "ls -la /workspace/nvda-q2-deck/ 2>/dev/null | head -30; which deckbuild"}, "tool_name": "shell"}
E0007Tool progress: shellDispatch: toolu_01BPNruk4LiHKvxn61vYPQFf
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01BPNruk4LiHKvxn61vYPQFf", "elapsed": null, "error": "", "fields": {"progress": {"message": "", "metadata": {"browser_chain": false, "command": "ls -la /workspace/nvda-q2-deck/ 2>/dev/null | head -30; which deckbuild", "phase": "starting"}}, "status": "running", "updatedAt": 1788576968765}, "result": null, "status": "running", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0008Tool result: shellDispatch: toolu_01BPNruk4LiHKvxn61vYPQFf
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01BPNruk4LiHKvxn61vYPQFf", "elapsed": 0.080585378, "error": "", "result": "total 358\ndrwxr-xr-x 2 user user 4096 Sep 5 01:18 .\ndrwxrwxrwx 6 user user 4096 Sep 5 02:52 ..\n-rw-r--r-- 1 user user 213796 Sep 5 01:18 deck.html\n-rw-r--r-- 1 user user 9477 Sep 5 01:18 deck.json\n-rw-r--r-- 1 user user 134578 Sep 5 01:18 deck.pptx\n/usr/local/bin/deckbuild\n", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0009Tool call: shellDispatch: toolu_01MNo1bqSiraUpfpJzxZU9TWEvidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01MNo1bqSiraUpfpJzxZU9TW", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"command": "cd /workspace/nvda-q2-deck && deckbuild outline deck.json 2>&1 | head -40 && deckbuild check deck.json 2>&1 | tail -20"}, "tool_name": "shell"}
E0010Tool progress: shellDispatch: toolu_01MNo1bqSiraUpfpJzxZU9TW
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01MNo1bqSiraUpfpJzxZU9TW", "elapsed": null, "error": "", "fields": {"progress": {"message": "", "metadata": {"browser_chain": false, "command": "cd /workspace/nvda-q2-deck && deckbuild outline deck.json 2>&1 | head -40 && deckbuild check deck.js...", "phase": "starting"}}, "status": "running", "updatedAt": 1788576974420}, "result": null, "status": "running", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0011Tool result: shellDispatch: toolu_01MNo1bqSiraUpfpJzxZU9TWEvidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01MNo1bqSiraUpfpJzxZU9TW", "elapsed": 1.838114434, "error": "", "result": "board deck — pyramid spine, action titles\n Answer first, then the support that earns it.\n\nRead only these. They should carry the argument to the recommendation\nwithout a single body line.\n\n 1 NVIDIA doubled revenue in a year and guided higher again\n 2 Revenue of $96.2 billion beat the quarter before it by 18%\n 3 Profit grew faster than revenue on a wider gross margin\n 4 § Data Center is now the company\n 5 Revenue has more than doubled across five quarters\n 6 Data Center grew 117% while Edge Computing grew 27%\n 7 Vera Rubin in full production is what carried the quarter\n 8 § Growth is now funded on the balance sheet\n 9 Cash conversion is the one line that went backwards this quarter.\n 10 Free cash flow fell to $21.3 billion even as net income rose\n 11 § The guide is the real news\n 12 Q3 is guided to $108 billion with no China Data Center revenue\n 13 Three things decide whether the guide converts to cash\n 14 Rebase FY27 models on the $108 billion Q3 guide\n\nMinto's order, and what a reader deciding something needs: state the answer on the first slide, then group the support beneath it. Each section divider states that section's conclusion, so the dividers alone are the skeleton of the argument.\n \"style\": [],\n \"storyline\": [],\n \"spine\": [\n \" 1 NVIDIA doubled revenue in a year and guided higher again\",\n \" 2 Revenue of $96.2 billion beat the quarter before it by 18%\",\n \" 3 Profit grew faster than revenue on a wider gross margin\",\n \" 4 \\u00a7 Data Center is now the company\",\n \" 5 Revenue has more than doubled across five quarters\",\n \" 6 Data Center grew 117% while Edge Computing grew 27%\",\n \" 7 Vera Rubin in full production is what carried the quarter\",\n \" 8 \\u00a7 Growth is now funded on the balance sheet\",\n \" 9 Cash conversion is the one line that went backwards this quarter.\",\n \" 10 Free cash flow fell to $21.3 billion even as net income rose\",\n \" 11 \\u00a7 The guide is the real news\",\n \" 12 Q3 is guided to $108 billion with no China Data Center revenue\",\n \" 13 Three things decide whether the guide converts to cash\",\n \" 14 Rebase FY27 models on the $108 billion Q3 guide\"\n ],\n \"geometry\": []\n}\n", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "shell"}
E0012Tool call: upload_fileDispatch: toolu_01LUqtVVJx3r2YLMmhSQcNDhEvidence cited by the judge
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01LUqtVVJx3r2YLMmhSQcNDh", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"path": "/workspace/nvda-q2-deck/deck.pptx"}, "tool_name": "upload_file"}
E0013Tool result: upload_fileDispatch: toolu_01LUqtVVJx3r2YLMmhSQcNDh
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_01LUqtVVJx3r2YLMmhSQcNDh", "elapsed": 0.544009654, "error": "", "result": {"artifact_keys": [{"attachment_url": "s3://sessions/a4f89dba-1cfe-49cd-bb20-5fb780abf2ee/uploads/e78ddb35-08c/deck.pptx", "path": "deck.pptx", "s3_key": "sessions/a4f89dba-1cfe-49cd-bb20-5fb780abf2ee/uploads/e78ddb35-08c/deck.pptx"}], "message": "File displayed to the user.", "status": "success"}, "status": "completed", "tool_name": "upload_file"}
E0014Tool call: send_messageDispatch: toolu_011K2Y7doFy3btDNrHMp5k4J
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_011K2Y7doFy3btDNrHMp5k4J", "handle": "", "panel_kind": "", "parent_dispatch_id": "", "tool_input": {"final": true, "message": "Here's the NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 deck (quarter ended July 26, 2026, reported Aug 26): 14 slides, board style, dark meridian palette, every figure sourced in the speaker notes.\n\nThe spine: $96.2B revenue (+106% y/y), 75.0% gross margin, Data Center $89.0B at 92% of the total, cash conversion slipping (FCF $21.3B vs $48.6B in Q1), and Q3 guided to $108B with zero China Data Center revenue assumed.\n\nWant it in your Drive as a Google Slides deck?"}, "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0015Tool result: send_messageDispatch: toolu_011K2Y7doFy3btDNrHMp5k4J
{"dispatch_id": "toolu_011K2Y7doFy3btDNrHMp5k4J", "elapsed": 6.419272858, "error": "", "result": "Delivered (confirmed) as 3 messages. Your draft was polished into texting register, so the wording differs from what you wrote; this is exactly what the user sees:\n1) Here's the NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 deck, covering the quarter ended July 26, 2026, reported August 26. It has 14 board style slides in a dark meridian palette, with every figure sourced in the speaker notes.\n2) The spine is $96.2B revenue, up 106% year over year, 75.0% gross margin, Data Center at $89.0B, and Q3 guidance of $108B with zero China Data Center revenue assumed.\n3) Want it in your Drive as a Google Slides deck?\nThese are your words now, and this is the whole reply: the delivery layer chose its density and shape by design. Never dispute, re-explain, or apologize for the phrasing, and never send a supplement to restore detail it left out. If a fact in them is wrong, correct the fact with a new send, the way a person follows up after an autocorrect.\n\nYour turn continues.\nanswers: ad86a9c7-4f38-49bc-bfad-d0e3b5e07585", "status": "completed", "tool_name": "send_message"}
E0016Assistant message
Here's the NVIDIA Q2 FY2027 deck, covering the quarter ended July 26, 2026, reported August 26. It has 14 board style slides in a dark meridian palette, with every figure sourced in the speaker notes.
E0017Assistant message
The spine is $96.2B revenue, up 106% year over year, 75.0% gross margin, Data Center at $89.0B, and Q3 guidance of $108B with zero China Data Center revenue assumed.
E0018Assistant message
Want it in your Drive as a Google Slides deck?